On Logic and Alternate Universes

[Edwardo Piet]

Ham....you need to quote as having done so.  Because you might be mixing up your contexts, lol.  OFC it violates the law of identity, as it applies in this universe.  That isn't in dispute between us.  However, if, in that universe, 2+2=5....the identity of the sum of two and two -is- 5, and cannot be -not 5-..assuming the law holds there as it applies in that universe.

Look. 2+2=4 is absolute as is the law of identity, what universe it is is irrelevant. You're just flat out wrong, we're talking about logical absolutes here, not logical concepts.

"2+2=4" is just an expression of "4=4" in another form. It's just the law of identity expressed in numbers. 2+2 has the same identity as 4, because it's the same thing, as does 3+1. 2+2 can not equal 5 because 5 is more than 2 and 2.

Please go and learn about logical absolutes. It doesn't matter what universe it is.