I answered all this repeatedly throughout the thread. The hypothetical is meaningless without the law of identity and hence can't be true with it.
I addressed the question repeatedly. Stop fucking telling me I'm not addressing a question that's invalid.
Can't logically have it? Same fucking thing as can't have it.
I addressed the question repeatedly. Stop fucking telling me I'm not addressing a question that's invalid.
Can't logically have it? Same fucking thing as can't have it.