(June 15, 2011 at 11:20 am)Cinjin Wrote: You do READ the thread before you post right????Yes. Your point is?
Cinjin Wrote:Hypotheticals do indeed serve to illuminate.Usually they do but not always, e.g. your hypothetical.
Cinjin Wrote:Only the reader can decide that however.True. So I didn’t. I wasn’t the only one who didn’t
Cinjin Wrote:Perhaps for you it does illuminate nothing, but that doesn't make your statement true.Nonsense. I found no point in your hypothetical. So my statement was true.
Cinjin Wrote:The only person who has even mentioned Deism on this thread is you. I don't proselytize.I didn’t say you did? But why would a deist come to an atheist webforum?
Cinjin Wrote:And to the last of your absurd statements: I agree, I was very obvious - how you missed that, I do not know.You were obvious. I stated that you were obvious. How is that absurd?
Using your words
Quote:I've debunked hypotheticals before Cinjin. Did the reality of this one hit home? Why so defensive?
I am sorry you do not like it that I found no point to your Heaven/Hell hypothetical question. Please don’t shoot me I’m only the messenger.