A question to all atheists!

[Gestas]

It appears so.

Looks like you don't have a good response for my last post. Oh well. You don't understand what possible world semantics is in modal logic, do you?

Let me repeat myself. Let's say there's a possible world where a natural world (including time) never existed. Could that possible world produce a natural world? Going by what you've said in the past (lul), the answer is no, which means you must think this natural world is past-eternal.

Hehe

And there you have it...

---

Eh, life's too short to waste any more of it on this idiot...

Too true. I think we have another classic case of a pigeon on the chess board here.