Theists: What is the most compelling argument you have heard for Atheism?

[Neo-Scholastic]

---

In order for my conclusion to be irrational, you would need to provide alternative reasons for landing the winning ticket despite the odds having enough zeros as the molecules in the universe (or half that, of halve that again--I don't care--it does not matter). If you say, "I don't know" then my reasoning that it was fixed is better than that. At least I have math providing good evidence that it was.

---

If you think there is not 100% established mind-boggling low probability, then you do not understand the issues. Physicists and cosmologists agree that the universe is finely tuned. Martin Rees, who wrote the list above (from the wikipedia article), has impeccable credentials: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Rees

In fact it is so well established that the multiverse theory was dreamed up to account for it!!

---

Augustine 1700 years ago did not take the Genesis account as a literal 6 days. If you think you are making a point, it is a tired-out one with no real meaning. Congrats.

---

The other thing in your example, is that you are only giving one drawing (although with incredibly high odds against).  I think that it can be granted that improbable things can and do occur.  However the way that statistics works, is that they do not happen consistently.  Now in the next drawing, you switch it up, and again, you get the exact combination required.  This happens again and again.   At some point, it's reasonable to expect that something is up.

Unless reality is absurd, chance must operate within some set parameters according to mathematical principles that transcend the randomized system in order to constrain it. The role of 2d6 produces a Bell curve distribution between 2 and 12. It never produces 13 or the square root of -1. So while the skeptics can appeal to chance, there must always be a rational order in the background.