Why them and not you?

[Mister Agenda]

You don't believe Theists when they testify they know God exists. I understand that and you shouldn't simply believe due to their testification.

But why should Theists take seriously that you actually are justified in not believing in God? Why should we not believe it's the fault of yours and not God's or anyone else?

Why should we take your testification that you sincerely sought to know whether God exists or not seriously?

Because we take you seriously about what you're saying and just point out that there are alternative explanations for what you've experienced.

You're calling us liars to our faces and presuming that you know our history and motivations better than we do. Assholes.

---

Because the existence of God is a positive existence claim. Substitute God for "invisible unicorn in my garage", maybe you get it then.

By the way, if most of the world claim to see an invisible unicorn in a garage, I would be prone to investigate their claim and not dismiss it.

The mere fact that they claim to see something invisible is a contradiction that would show that most of the world is spouting nonsense. Is the invisible unicorn also pink?