Oh no not another free will thread.

[Paraselene]

People have called me alot of things...but I don't think I've ever been accused of that, lol. 

What I'm pointing out, is that -if- that conjecture is true, it's a problem for classical free will.  That's the position you've been attempting to argue against, as somehow not making sense.  It makes sense, even if neither of us buys into that god story or thinks that the universe works that way.

I understand your "if" scenario. I was just joshing up above.

However, even under the "if" scenario, I don't see the logic you're attempting to apply.