RE: Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission, Round 2
August 21, 2018 at 6:00 pm
(This post was last modified: August 21, 2018 at 6:02 pm by Tiberius.)
@Catholic_Lady
I don’t think the baker should be forced to write anything on the cake they don’t want to. However if the people ask for a gay pride cake, with rainbow colors, etc then the Baker should make it,
The line/test for me is: would the baker refuse to bake the same cake if the use was not obvious.
In other words, if a straight man requests a rainbow colored cake with sprinkles, and the baker is fine with that request, it should not be denied just because a gay man requests the exact same cake for a gay pride party.
The trans cake is a great example btw. If all the person asked for was a blue cake with a pink center, it shouldn’t make a damn of difference whether it’s for a cisgender or transgender.
I don’t think the baker should be forced to write anything on the cake they don’t want to. However if the people ask for a gay pride cake, with rainbow colors, etc then the Baker should make it,
The line/test for me is: would the baker refuse to bake the same cake if the use was not obvious.
In other words, if a straight man requests a rainbow colored cake with sprinkles, and the baker is fine with that request, it should not be denied just because a gay man requests the exact same cake for a gay pride party.
The trans cake is a great example btw. If all the person asked for was a blue cake with a pink center, it shouldn’t make a damn of difference whether it’s for a cisgender or transgender.
