My proofs for Islam

[LadyForCamus]

That’s not what I said, and you know it.  Please see my edited last post where I address this.

Oh, ok, phrase how you understand my argument in your own words. I wasn't dismissing brain and relationship to perception. What I was saying, it's either us/our brains that generates the concept of self (who we are, all psychological traits, etc) or something else. Then I also argued why I think it's impossible for anything but God to perceive an accurate reality of who we are.

You can’t go anywhere in your argument until you:

1. Demonstrate that “the self” is something more than the product of a functioning brain.

2. Successfully rule out the possibility that these selves could exist absent a god.  

You need to accomplish the above before you can even open up this “perception” can ‘o’ worms.