If it wasn't for religion

[Acrobat]

Okay so, you believe Goodness and badness are not "stuff", they're are mental designations of what acts belong to conceptual sets and why we think so.


And that these mental designations exist independent of our minds, as a part of objective reality. Or in other words in your view reality possess mental properties?

If not can you explain how mental designations have an existence independent of minds.

It's like 2 + 2 = 4. It is so no matter what anyone thinks about it, yet it doesn't mean there is a literal 2 or 4 out there.

2+2 = 4, is just another way of saying if you have two dollars, and I give you two more dollars, you’d have four dollars.

So two is literal here.