If it wasn't for religion

[Acrobat]

Tossing jews into the ovens possess all the properties of tossing Jews into the oven, that’s it.

...................and? OFC tossing jews into ovens possesses all of the properties of tossing jews into ovens...............

A pizza from dominos possess all the properties in which I am referring to as (tastes) good. The correct proportion of cheese to meat ratio, the correct degree of crispness, etc..

Therefore good is a material property of dominos pizza.

Sure, I'm entirely certain that what tastes good to you comes down to a material property of that thing (many, from the looks of it).

In fact, you might even be able to create a rule of what tastes good to you with enough data...since "correct proportion of cheese to meat ratio, the correct degree of crispiness, etc" can be applied to more than just a pizza.

Sure, even If i sucked at discerning all the elements that compose the things that I find taste good, it’s possible that I could feed a computer with all the different foods that I like, and it churns out a variety of things to try, with a high predictably that I’d find those things to be good as well.

This seems to be true of all our subjective preferences, like music, fashion, movies, the sort of people we find good looking, ugly etc.

All the things that go into the good category and bad category, are based on a variety of physical traits and criteria of the things being categorized one way or the other. You’ll find bland foods in the bad category, spicy and sweet foods in the good category, dark skinned, skinny girls in the good category, fat, pail girls in the bad category. Music that sounds like Justin Bieber in the good category, music that sounds like death metal in the bad category.

If we applied your logic, at the end of the day all the things that would have fallen into the subjective category, would now fall under the objective category, without any real substantive change taking place in this transition.

Good becomes a property of the objects themselves. Justin Bieber being a good musician becomes an objective fact, and no longer a subjective preference.