(August 12, 2019 at 9:36 pm)Grandizer Wrote:(August 12, 2019 at 9:31 pm)Acrobat Wrote: Let’s ask this of a subjective good, like dominos pizza is good, where dominos pizza is x. Let’s introduce a y as well which stands for my taste buds.
Is good here something about x, or good here something about y?
Perhaps you recognize in this example that good is really about y, good is description of my likes.
Your not going to find the “good” in the pizza, it’s located in me, in this example of a subjective good. Do you agree?
Both. It's in my perception but it also depends on something about the pizza that makes me like it.
IOW:
The pizza tastes good, so I like it.
(August 12, 2019 at 9:31 pm)Acrobat Wrote: Let’s ask this of a subjective good, like dominos pizza is good, where dominos pizza is x. Let’s introduce a y as well which stands for my taste buds.
Is good here something about x, or good here something about y?
Perhaps you recognize in this example that good is really about y, good is description of my likes.
Your not going to find the “good” in the pizza, it’s located in me, in this example of a subjective good. Do you agree?
If it was my answer, would that have been an adequate response? This is the type of response you were looking for? Am I correct?
Is it your answer? Yes or no?
It’s not both though. If I were to take this pizza to a lab dissect it, I’m not going to locate some property called “good” in it, the location of “good”, is in your subjective biological state, it’s in you rather than in the pizza.
