Agnosticism IS the most dishonest position

[The Grand Nudger]

No, I already told you, I have moral objections to his character and his ethics.  This makes him unsuitable as a cult leader, and makes his cult unsuitable, to me.

I think you only hear what you want to hear. I already said you can't object morally to his character mainly because he doesn't belong to your era. You need a stronger case against him  than simply saying "not my jam" and/or name calling.

I'm obviously not hearing anything that I want to hear...what with what I'm hearing being the reason I couldn't be a member of your club.  I really don't need a stronger case for why I do or don't join any club. 

Your club says things I can't co-sign, therefore I'm not interested in being in your club.  This can't be hard to understand.  

I like to tell your christian brethren that I'm just not a winnable soul.  The things that you consider to be true, the truth that you would have me affirm, repulse me as a person of good character and strong conscience.

Again, you're referring to yourself - more precisely, to your tastes - as judge and jury over the entire history. Until now you didn't give any objective underlying reason for your distaste against the prophets.

I'm the judge and jury over whether or not I can join a club, and why, Kloro.  Your founder was evil and your religion is morally abhorrent.  Not objective enough?  What would be, you tell me.  Honestly.  What do you think would be a sufficiently objective reason...for me....not to join a club? Or...how about this, let me propose something to you.

I know this guy, you should give him oral sex. It's superfun and awesome and everyone should be doing it. Do you want to join the club? Why, or why not?