(June 25, 2021 at 5:16 pm)Angrboda Wrote: None of this says anything about free will. You've created an irrelevant argument about nothing. P1 being true doesn't mean daughter D has free will. Nor does P1 and P3 being consistent.
It does. P1 is a sufficient condition for free will. An agent has free will == he's able to choose (at least once in his life) from a set of actions.
P1 means D freely chose her flavor of ice cream today, therefore, by definition, D has free will.