forbidding people to love each other

[The Grand Nudger]

a things naturalness ir unnatural ness is not equivalent to its rightness or wrongness.

I agree. but it seems that, if something is unnatural it's more likely to be wrong. If natural means serving our natural needs of survival/procreation. Then anything unnatural like males copulating with males instead of females is clearly a faulty allocation of resources. A male would rather share his genetic makeup with a female to serve the purpose of procreation.

That’s not why I have sex, but again, I’m definitely gonna whisper that in my wife’s ear one night in bed.

At any rate, why does it matter how it seems when we’ve both agreed that we know it is not logically so?

But I admit it's hard to make a case against homosexuality without referring to some religious repertoire...

It really isn’t. It’s incredibly simple to make a case against anything from virtually any angle- but as your last attempt reasserted here even though you understand it’s false shows... it’s a bit more difficult to make a good o e.

I doubt that your silly god is the missing ingredient. You could always try, but my expectation is that it will be an even worse argument than the last.