(September 10, 2024 at 2:58 pm)snowtracks Wrote:(September 10, 2024 at 12:40 pm)Mister Agenda Wrote: If you can show the rate of expansion could have had a different value, there's a Nobel waiting for you. And if the rate of expansion had been slightly faster, we still get a universe.If faster, galaxies & stars wouldn't have formed.
You can have a garbage bin.
You can try to throw a ball of paper into the bin.
If the ball of paper is too slow, it will land outside the bin.
If it is too fast, it lands outside the bin.
If the speed is just right, it lands inside the bin.
Unfortunately, this concept doesn't tell us who threw the ball, if it was a human, an alien, a god, an alien-god, smurfs, some ball throwing machine, or just nature.
There is no evidence of any magical man doing anything.
There was a moment in time when it was thought that thunder, lightning was cause by the gods.
There was a moment when it was thought that disease was done by the gods.
There was a moment when it was thought that the gods control pregnancy. “They bless you with a child”.
It was thought that when the gods bless you get get better crops.
If you do sacrifices, if you offer some animal, your first born kid or some virgin (the gods have sex with virgins?), the gods accept your gift and as a thank you note, they do you a favor.
Such things have been replaced by science. Once science gives an explanation, we never return to the god of the gaps argument