(March 22, 2012 at 5:54 pm)LastPoet Wrote:(March 22, 2012 at 5:45 pm)ChadWooters Wrote: False dilemma based on an incorrect understanding of heaven and hell. Heaven and hell are not places. Each describes the soul's spiritual condition in relationship to god. It's not possible for an evil person to be in a heavenly state. Nor is it possible for a good person of good intent to be in a hellish one.(emphasis mine)
Please notice I made no reference to religious affiliation or lack thereof.
Yes, but you did made a bunch of claims there as I marked. Please explain your reasoning there. And provide evidence for a 'spiritual condition'. While you're at it, provide evidence that we have a 'soul'.
PS- and define 'soul', 'god', 'heaven' and 'hell' while you're at it.
I answered the question directly to show how it presented a straw man. The concepts for which you desire clarification and proof are currently being discussed on other threads in depth using a serious approach.
