Eilonnwy,
JP keeps reposting large parts of his arguments so a bunch of the posts are mostly copy paste jobs. Dotard did a nice job of capturing the essence of the argument, although I feel he should have thrown in a few epistemologies, a dash of non-contingents, oh, and ye, let us not forget ontology.
I still maintain that circular argument is circular (yes I know repetition does not an argument make, but at least I am not merely reposting paragraphs of my argument)
Rhizo
JP keeps reposting large parts of his arguments so a bunch of the posts are mostly copy paste jobs. Dotard did a nice job of capturing the essence of the argument, although I feel he should have thrown in a few epistemologies, a dash of non-contingents, oh, and ye, let us not forget ontology.
I still maintain that circular argument is circular (yes I know repetition does not an argument make, but at least I am not merely reposting paragraphs of my argument)
Rhizo