(September 3, 2012 at 5:13 pm)Rhythm Wrote:(September 3, 2012 at 5:08 pm)idunno Wrote: You can only choose what you choose, you can't choose otherwise. If you choose A, you're stuck with A. If B, then B. Both Options are on the table, but you can only actually choose one (with or without God). Whatever option you choose, you can't choose the other.None of which addresses what I just posted to you, at all. I just asked you if you could make a choice and you told me no, but now you say that I can?
Quote: This is the case even with God outta the picture. So having chose your choice, God knows the choice you pick.
I thought he knew it before I chose it, you mean god has to wait until I make choices to know the outcome? Well fuck idunno -I can do that, this guy is sounding less like a superhero and more like my completely average uncle all of a sudden....So, not omniscient?
Haha, I've never argued that you can't make a choice, if that's what you've taken from what I've said you've misunderstood me. My whole point is that a choice does not necessitate alternative options.
I suppose implicit in all of this is the distinction between chronological and logical priority. God's foreknowledge is chronologically prior, but my choice is logically prior. His foreknowing doesn't make my choice for me, I do.
