(September 22, 2012 at 2:09 pm)MysticKnight Wrote: Exactly, but Quran shows disbelievers can become believers and not only can, but that most in Arabia did.
Therefore you have a contradiction.
No Muslim will believe it's impossible for disbeliever to be guided towards Islam. Faith is something to be said that doesn't happen unless God wills it.
This looks like a slip up from the Prophet.
Could mean disbelievers as atheists only. So anyone who is from another religion can convert but not atheists.
