(November 21, 2012 at 10:51 am)Darkstar Wrote: AlsoOkay this is an easy one so I'll address it first. John 7:53–8:11 isn't actually in the Bible, so addressing it or relying on it for any kind of wisdom is in err. This is why we have textual criticism!this passage is unusual. It isn't unusual for Jesus's merciful character, but isn't Jesus explicitly contradicting Yahweh here?
Quote:I have pointed out that Jesus's and Yahweh's conflicting moralities suggest that they aren't really the same person. You assume that they must be. When god is in a good mood, he massacres people he doesn't like. When god is angry, he massacres...people who annoy him. Jesus preaches forgiveness and non-violence, whereas Yahweh leads brutal military campaigns and commands his followers to show no mercy. How do you reconcile this?Again, the Christian God is known through Jesus, if He is immoral then prove Jesus was immoral. If you want to go to a more complicated argument surrounding the characterization of God in the Old Testament, then you need to first understand the character of Jesus in the New Testament. The Old Testament is very long and contains a huge amount of information, taking all the passages where God is angry and referring to only those passages is akin to cherry picking. If I'm not allowed to cherry pick from the Bible, then neither are atheists.