(December 9, 2012 at 8:58 pm)Al-Fatihah Wrote: Response: Hitler didn't do the challenge, as the challenge proves. As for Muhammad succeeding the challenge, it was answered. I'm only one person. I can't answer dozens of post all at once. You'll just have to be patient until I get to it, which was just answered.
I just rejected you answer. You say that eyewitnesses are not reliable because they might not actually be eyewitnesses, and we shouldn't take their word for it because that would be hearsay.
[quote Al-Fatihah]Yet if asked how you know that these historians were eyewitnesses, your answer is "because they said so", thus you debunked yourself again. For it still relies on hearsay that the eyewitness were actually eyewitness.[/quote]
If we can't trust modern historians then how can we trust ancient nobodies?
