The qurayza slaughterd themselves literally in accordance with their own law for treason.
Muhammad pbuh did not judge but it was the leader of the banu Qurayza tribe who proscribed the punishment which was in accordance with the Jewish law and not the law Muhammad pbuh came with - hence why Muhammad did not have all Jews killed (though some prejudiced atheists and evangelical Christians hope upon hope that this happened to pretend that the Muslims were anywhere near as awful as Christians). Hence why you find century upon century of Jewish and Muslim people living pecefully side by side with only exceptional cases of anything different - exceptional cases that illogical people would LOVE to pretend is the norm because they can't accept what the respected and mainstream historians tell us: Muslims and Jews had a peacefull coexistence that never happened in Cheistendom where the shameful treatment of Jews culminated in full scale genocide during the crusades)
I'm not demanding you accept the truth of Islam - but I am asking you: be honest with yourself. This picture of Muslims slaughtering Jews is only propaganda of the Christian far right who want to paint their dark side on to another people and try to play victimhood one-up-manship.
I'm not telling you you must be a Muslim but at least respect the objective and study to find out real human history. Even if Islam was false consciousness(which it is not) the image of Muslims versus Jews throughout history just doesn't stand up: we are different from Christians - even if some of us look scary and brown we do not have a history of genocide against Jews!
Muhammad pbuh did not judge but it was the leader of the banu Qurayza tribe who proscribed the punishment which was in accordance with the Jewish law and not the law Muhammad pbuh came with - hence why Muhammad did not have all Jews killed (though some prejudiced atheists and evangelical Christians hope upon hope that this happened to pretend that the Muslims were anywhere near as awful as Christians). Hence why you find century upon century of Jewish and Muslim people living pecefully side by side with only exceptional cases of anything different - exceptional cases that illogical people would LOVE to pretend is the norm because they can't accept what the respected and mainstream historians tell us: Muslims and Jews had a peacefull coexistence that never happened in Cheistendom where the shameful treatment of Jews culminated in full scale genocide during the crusades)
I'm not demanding you accept the truth of Islam - but I am asking you: be honest with yourself. This picture of Muslims slaughtering Jews is only propaganda of the Christian far right who want to paint their dark side on to another people and try to play victimhood one-up-manship.
I'm not telling you you must be a Muslim but at least respect the objective and study to find out real human history. Even if Islam was false consciousness(which it is not) the image of Muslims versus Jews throughout history just doesn't stand up: we are different from Christians - even if some of us look scary and brown we do not have a history of genocide against Jews!
Kudos given by (1): Dawud
