(June 6, 2013 at 5:36 pm)Statler Waldorf Wrote: Nope, a contradiction has to be at the same time and in the same relationship, in relation to the Greek and Roman Gods I am an atheist (believe in no such god), but in relation to Yahweh I am a theist (believe in such a god), the wheels have officially fallen off of your wagon.
You conveniently added the word "such" to your definition, which is a contradiction of your own position that people do not have the authority to modify a definition in any way.
So, which is it:
Belief in no god?
or
Belief in no such god?
And you think my wheels have officially fallen off?
Quote:I already have it figured out, but that’s irrelevant either way, my opinion does not change the proper definition of atheism which is the affirmation in the non-existence of God or gods. You should change the name of this thread to “Atheist’s misperceptions about their own position.”
No, I should change the name of the thread to:
Statler says everyone else is wrong!