A Serious Question For Theists

[Whateverist]

A little while back on this thread, I asked GC directly whether he thought it was possible for someone who once felt and thought as a xtian to become an atheist. I was surprised that he said he did think so, that some atheists had truly been xtians but lost their faith. Had to give him props for that given how common it is for xtians to pull out the "no true xtian' objection.