"I may be fat, but I beat my eating disorder"

[paulpablo]

I think you're wrong because I don't think this single message is designed to be for everyone to listen to, it's just for a specific set of people with eating disorders and an unhealthy workout obsession.

There's loads of stuff that annoys me about the website but the health message isn't one of them because I don't think it's designed to be followed as a universal health message.
And just because a girl isn't good at the bleep test or able to do a pull up doesn't mean she is unhealthy unless you're defining health as purely athletic functionality. Which is an understandable definition of health, but usually when people talk about health it's a more broader definition.

This is just my opinion based on the information given. She doesn't seem to specify on the website what her diet is now, what exercise she does now (beyond a bit of dancing).

The main thing I do find annoying about the website is the title, redefining beauty.
It wasn't defined objectively because it's subjective anyway, and a girl losing weight then gaining it back and taking lots of selfies isn't going to change that.
I personally do like non athletic girls, size 8-14, just because I don't like muscles on a girl but too much fat disgusts me.
Her amount of fat isn't too much in my humble opinion but I'd say she should strictly maintain to that level and not put on more weight, it's what I'd call chubby. When you reach size 16 in my opinion that's fat.