What would you consider to be evidence for God?

[robvalue]

For me, pragmatic scepticism at a personal level should be graded not just on the unlikelihood of the claim but also the importance. So even if blue whales don't exist, it doesn't make much difference to me. If atoms don't exist, my understanding of things would be a bit shaken up, but still it wouldn't affect me. So I'm happy to rely on a robust but not highly critical level of inspection and "trust".

However, if you're planning to devote your life to something, donate money, preach to others about it, life your life by its values and so on... I'd say it's pretty fucking important to be very sure that it actually exists!