RE: How old is the Earth?
October 15, 2010 at 5:57 am
(This post was last modified: October 15, 2010 at 6:08 am by Anomalocaris.)
(October 15, 2010 at 5:26 am)TheDarkestOfAngels Wrote:(October 15, 2010 at 5:06 am)Chuck Wrote: We are talking about different things. Of course radioactive isotopes can react chemically just like their nonradioactive isotopes. Different Isotopes shares the same electron configuration, so are chemically very similar. What I meant is chemical reactions can not alter the weight and charge of the nucleus, which determines the radioactivity of the isotope. So no chemistry can change rate of radioactive decay.
Chemistry can in some cases mobilize either parent or daughter elements. But that's different from changing the rate of decay. Furthermore we know chemistry well enough to exclude this possibility from most radioactive dating. If an volcano boils away daughter elements, it would tend to make the mineral look younger than it is. So it would be All the more embarrassing if the erroneous young age thus derived still exceeds 6000 years by a large margin.
Oh. I see where I was mistaken and this is certainly much more serious a matter.
The only way to change the nucleus of an atom in this fashion at a speed different than radioactive decay would have to involve nuclear fusion or nuclear fission - both of which would either require or generate far more power than is available outside of reactor, a particle accelerator, or the heart of the sun. All of these options would melt the earth.
Even the biggest stars in the universe don't generate uranium until it goes supernova or it hypernovas.
Nucleus can also change if struck by extremely energetic cosmic ray particles. But the frequency of occurrence is rare compared to the number of reactions in reactors or the like. Spontaneous self-sustaining nuclear fission on a small scale is also known to have occurred in naturally occurring uranium deposits on earth. Basically actions of ground water concentrated fissile material into deposits exceeding critical mass, so the uranium deposit began a sustained chain reaction outputing a few MW for a few tens of thousands of years until the fissile material is used up.