(June 6, 2010 at 5:03 pm)Purple Rabbit Wrote:
Okay...
First of all, I haven't read Leibniz, so I'll have to defer to you on what he meant. It appears to be a circular argument (yet again):
a) God is both omnipotent and omnibenevolent
b) Therefore, we must live in the best of all possible worlds
c) Therefore, the problem of evil is solved
d) Therefore, god is both omnipotent and omnibenevolent
Not very convincing, I'm afraid.
In reply to your numbered points:
1. Yes, thats obviously true.
2. Maybe. I think that its a fair assumption that there are other nomologically possible worlds, given that microphysics appears to be stochastic. Iow: with a stochastic microphysics, there are other possible present states of the universe, given identical starting conditions. Makes sense to me.
3. I don't need to. In fact, I concede the issue in my first point. The argument hinges on 'god' being limited by logical rather than nomological possibility. Unless you're prepared to argue that the two are identical (i.e. that our physical laws are somehow metaphysically necessary), then its hard to see how a better universe isn't logically possible.
I'll try to re-phrase the argument:
1. We assume that we really do live in the best of all nomologically possible worlds.
2. However, it is very easy to imagine a better world ('heaven' might serve as some sort of model here).
3. Therefore, we do not live in the best of all logically possible worlds.
4. 'God' is only limited by what is logically possible (he is omnipotent).
5. Therefore, god could have instantiated a different world from the set of logically possible worlds. Some of the different worlds that he could've instantiated would be better than ours.
6. But he didn't. He instantiated our world, which is not the best logically possible world even if it is the best nomologically possible world.
7. Therefore, god is a cunt.
He who desires to worship God must harbor no childish illusions about the matter but bravely renounce his liberty and humanity.
Mikhail Bakunin
A casual stroll through the lunatic asylum shows that faith does not prove anything
Friedrich Nietzsche
Mikhail Bakunin
A casual stroll through the lunatic asylum shows that faith does not prove anything
Friedrich Nietzsche