Rhyhtm Wrote:-and so what, again.....the op wants a coherent universe, if we place the law of identity there, referent to what occurs in their universe when two quantities of two things yields five quantities of that thing,
Such a hypothetical can't be hypothesized.
Quote: in order to make something follow and give us something to talk about.....but all of the other rules are different, so that..for example...two quantities of two things can yield the sum of five things...is that sufficient condition to call those rules, whatever they are, logical rules?
Dude. How many times. You can't have a hypothetical that violates the law of identity and you've already agreed that 2+2=5 violates it.