Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: November 17, 2026, 10:07 pm

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
#11
RE: Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
(July 23, 2012 at 10:12 pm)FallentoReason Wrote: Nope. Just a standard literal interpretation of what was going on.
Then at that point it ceases to be a "Bible study."


Quote:It's not any more 'real' than mine was.
your map was not to scale nor did it include any topography.

Quote:This one is simply slanted so that you can draw a horizontal line between Galilee and Gerasa. This doesn't make it opposite Galilee because Gerasa isn't based on the shores of the Sea of Galilee, as Luke makes it out to be:
It was based on a google maps satelite image that gave a natural perspective.

Quote:Then they arrived at the country of the Gerasenes, which is opposite Galilee. As he stepped out on land, a man of the city who had demons met him.
This refers to a Region "The Land of Gerasenes" I does not say "with in the city walls of Gerasenes" which is what the dot on either map repersents. For Gerasenes was the captiol of persia and had boarders that expanded beyond the city walls.

Quote:Nothing about walking x miles to Gerasa.
6 miles from the sea http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umm_Qais there is a good pic of the ruins on a hill looking down to the sea that gives a great understanding of how the two are related.

Quote:They simply got out of the boat at 'Gerasa' and they found the man. This is all perfectly possible if it was Capernaum because Capernaum is on the shore of the Sea of Galilee.
this guy slept in tombs. even in gentile cities the tombs were found outside the city walls in that time. And if the people considered this man to have a 'demon' (whether he did or not) he would have been forced to live out of the city walls.

Quote:When the reference has 3 numbers (x:y:z) I'm pretty sure it means book x, chapter y, paragraph/verse z. Sorry, I should have clarified.
Book three of Josepheus is Flavius Josephus Against Apion, not the war of the Jews. that is book two. If you look at how the books are subdivided you have book chapter and phragraph. There arn't any verses in the unmolested translation of the Works of Josepheus.

That is why I ask that yoou provide your version, maybe it was a study based work or a commentary based work. that subdivided the work further than what I was referencing.


Quote:Wow, you're absolutely right. I've let my guard down on this one.. I honestly thought this Gospel was somewhat equivalent to the Gospel of Thomas in that it was written around those times, but clearly Wikipedia shows me this Gospel is an outlier. Thanks, you've reminded me to always do the extra research and never take stuff at face value.
Confused Fall

Quote:This doesn't mean there's nothing to be looked at here. Luke still talks about this 'Legion' thing. Maybe he should have named it something else OR.... perhaps that was his intention? To link his 'event' to the massacre fresh in people's minds.
Or perhaps there is a demon or a collection of them that goes by that name. Which luke would have been bound to record.

Quote:There's no need to 'smash' things together. Put them all side by side and the parallels are obvious; pigs/Jews drowning, 'Legion' i.e. Romans being the cause...
Again unless you smash them together, indivisually these events are unrelated. It is only when a compareson is forced does any of this work together.

Quote:Yes, the Gospel of Barnabas was written after for sure, but Josephus' War came before.
perhaps before barnabus, but it is a disputed matter if it came before the works of luke.


Quote:The only thing saying that it must have been before 70 A.D. is that none of the Gospels say the prophecy of the temple was fulfilled. This cuts both ways for us and therefore doesn't become very useful. Your view in a nutshell: Jesus was divine, this prophecy came to be. My view in a nutshell: allegories that are alluding to recent events that happened i.e. the destruction of the temple.

Josephus still stands.
Not if luke was written before the war. which if you simply follow what was written in the two books. The book of acts ends with the beginning of Paul's ministry in rome (about 3 years before his death) which puts the completeion of the book of Acts around 64 AD well before the recorded works of Josephus (75AD) We know the Book of Luke was completed well before the book of Acts because we know Luke was a Servant of Theolopus (personal physician) when He wrote the book of Luke. At the time the book of Acts was written He had dedicated his life to the ministry as a deciple of the apstole Paul. Something he could not do if he were still 'owned' by theolopus.

Which puts the completion of both of lukes works before the death of Paul. which was before any of the works of Josephus.
Reply
#12
RE: Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it" ~ Aristotle
Reply
#13
RE: Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
Reply
#14
RE: Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it" ~ Aristotle
Reply
#15
RE: Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
Reply
#16
RE: Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
I can see you're trying to be very noble and I appreciate that, but how about you respond to my arguments? I don't need 'faith' to see what Luke did. There's still reason to believe his dishonest attempt at conversions, unless you have something proper to say against my last post. Try again.
"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it" ~ Aristotle
Reply
#17
RE: Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
(July 26, 2012 at 12:20 am)FallentoReason Wrote: I can see you're trying to be very noble and I appreciate that, but how about you respond to my arguments? I don't need 'faith' to see what Luke did. There's still reason to believe his dishonest attempt at conversions, unless you have something proper to say against my last post. Try again.

There is nothing to respond to. I gave you a time line that puts the works of luke about 20 years before the works of Joseuphs, I eliminated the works of barnabus, and the bit concerning the map.

So now you return to the works of Josephus despite what was said, and you take an account that was written some time after the life of Christ (for another purpose all together) and simply 'believe' that it is the inspiration of the works of Luke.. (And appearently Matthew and Mark as well for do not forget they both record the event.)

To which I said was fine, but also told you that your efforts were the result of Faith, and not 'reason.' I am not here to argue your faith, or what you simple wish to be true. I am here to simply clear up or straighten out any biblically based misunderstandings.
Reply
#18
RE: Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
Drich Wrote:There is nothing to respond to. I gave you a time line that puts the works of luke about 20 years before the works of Joseuphs, I eliminated the works of barnabus, and the bit concerning the map.

20 years is a huge exaggeration. Luke was written in 55 A.D?? You're dreaming Wink. My framework consists of understanding the first Gospel written, Mark, which was after the destruction of the temple putting it at no earlier than 70 A.D. Then a synoptic understanding would mean Matthew and Luke logically came after Mark making it fair game that Luke could have been written after War of the Jews.

I agree about the Gospel of Barnabas and the geographic dispute. Tomorrow I'll sort through the evidence again and put forth what remains of it that still makes sense in light of our discussion thus far.

Quote:So now you return to the works of Josephus despite what was said, and you take an account that was written some time after the life of Christ (for another purpose all together) and simply 'believe' that it is the inspiration of the works of Luke.. (And appearently Matthew and Mark as well for do not forget they both record the event.)

As I see it, this is the new frontier of the discussion now, which I will clear up tomorrow because I'm going to bed.

Quote:To which I said was fine, but also told you that your efforts were the result of Faith, and not 'reason.' I am not here to argue your faith, or what you simple wish to be true. I am here to simply clear up or straighten out any biblically based misunderstandings.

I can assure you your judgement of my efforts is wrong. It's most definitely not faith based. I wrote up this thread seeing the reasons for why I was right and thanks to your determination we've cleared some things up. I hope you realise by now that I've admitted to conceding a point several times. I don't have an agenda or 'wish things to be true'. I simply want the truth and nothing but the truth.

On a side note: don't ever compare me to other atheists. In all honesty I hate that word because no matter how much people will repeat it's meaning I still see it as carrying baggage. I'm a free thinker that is open to anything provided you show me the reasons for why it is so. I'm all ears to what you have to say.
"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it" ~ Aristotle
Reply
#19
RE: Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
The parallels as I see them now:

Josephus
>Jews drowning close to the coast
>Roman legions being responsible

Luke
>'Legion' being a collection of demons
>'Legion' making pigs drown at the coast
"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it" ~ Aristotle
Reply
#20
RE: Uncovering the Lucan Allegory
(July 27, 2012 at 12:14 pm)FallentoReason Wrote: The parallels as I see them now:

Josephus
>Jews drowning close to the coast
>Roman legions being responsible

Luke
>'Legion' being a collection of demons
>'Legion' making pigs drown at the coast

As I point out what you 'believe' is based in simply faith. I am not here to take that from you. If you want to believe this then you are free to do so.
Reply



Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Allegory vs. Literal Fact in the Bible rexbeccarox 21 7766 April 26, 2013 at 2:36 am
Last Post: Dragonetti
  Uncovering the Markan Allegory II FallentoReason 14 6267 September 10, 2012 at 12:01 am
Last Post: FallentoReason
  Uncovering the Markan Allegory II FallentoReason 11 6485 July 27, 2012 at 9:18 am
Last Post: The Grand Nudger
  Uncovering the Markan Allegory FallentoReason 7 5521 July 11, 2012 at 3:26 am
Last Post: FallentoReason
  Primordial Sex--Eden as Allegory Barre 139 81444 January 22, 2012 at 7:56 pm
Last Post: Epimethean



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)