response, to al fatihah

[paulpablo]

This is my private message to al fatihah who condones sex with 9 year olds
me./
all arguements about words and context aside theres really no argument to be had anyway, im just making a statement that i think youre a disgusting human being for thinking that sex between a girl of 9 years old and a man over 40 is fine and theres nothing wrong with it.
That was the original point i was making before we got side tracked with your definition of what a model is
al fatihaha/

Response: That only demonstrates that you're actually the filthy disgusting person. For there is no harm in consensual sex at puberty with someone who is mature. Saying otherwise implies that you ondone nonconsensual sex, thus rape and molestation. Thus exposing youeself as usual, not islam.

He has an interesting opinion that if you think sex with a 9 year old is wrong then you must be the one who condones rape and molestation, i pretty much believe the exact opposite, i believe that sex with a 9 year old is molestation, what is your opinion?

[Dee Dee Ramone]

Response: When you can provide evidence of harm done in having consensul sex in marriage with a 9 year old who has reached maturity and and puberty, other than because mommy says so, then you will have a point.

I nominated this post in the hall of shame. His fundamentalistic and pervert interpretation of Islam is more blasphemic than all of us atheists' efforts combined.

[Darwinian]

So what he is saying is that as long as Jimmy Sa'vile' could persuade an 11 year old girl to have sex with him then that's all fine and lovely and Islam would totally support it?

Is that what he's saying?

Not sure we want someone like this here really.

[Something completely different]

He doesn`t care what others think of it.


He`s a fanatic, you could catch him actualy having sex with a minor, call the police, have a trial, and have him sentenced.
He would still defend this view.

[Al-Fatihah]

He has an interesting opinion that if you think sex with a 9 year old is wrong then you must be the one who condones rape and molestation, i pretty much believe the exact opposite, i believe that sex with a 9 year old is molestation, what is your opinion?

Response: Amusing, when that was never stated. Yet what was clearly stated is the there is absolutely nothing wrong with consensual sex in marriage at puberty with someone who is mature. What you stated is that this is a wrongful act. Therefore, your own logic supports the idea of molesting a child, and having sex without consent. So tell us, what makes you think it's okay to be such a perv?

[Something completely different]

Response: Amusing, when that was never stated. Yet what was clearly stated is the there is absolutely nothing wrong with consensual sex in marriage at puberty with someone who is mature. What you stated is that this is a wrongful act. Therefore, your own logic supports the idea of molesting a child, and having sex without consent. So tell us, what makes you think it's okay to be such a perv?

"absolutly nothing wrong"??????

Puperty starts between 10-12 years of age of the individual.

Let`s just ask one simple question:

Is it alright for a 40 year old male muslim, to be married and to have sex with a 10 year old girl, who has reached puperty?


Personaly I think the case wis very clear. A person reaches adulthood at 18, and at that point can have sex with people above the age of 18 as much as they want.

And I find nothing about this subject to be

amusing

paulpoablo never stated that he supported the molestation of a child. He clearly spoke out against such, in fact the purpose of this thread is to voice his disgust about your support for childabuse.
There is nothing which would in any way suppose that "by his logic" he would support the molestation of a child.

You are the one who stated that when reaching puperty it is alright for such a person to be married and to have sex with an adult.

Do not reflect your undefenciable possition on someone else when you find it to be undefendable.

[Darwinian]

Yet what was clearly stated is the there is absolutely nothing wrong with consensual sex in marriage at puberty with someone who is mature.

I just want to clarify this as I can't rule out the possibility of a breakdown in communication somewhere along the line.

Are you stating that as long as the girl is going through puberty, is married and gives consent then it is perfectly permissible, normal, allowable etc. for a 10 year old girl to have a full sexual relationship with say, a 50 year old man?

A simple yes or no will suffice.

[LastPoet]

Response: Amusing, when that was never stated. Yet what was clearly stated is the there is absolutely nothing wrong with consensual sex in marriage at puberty with someone who is mature. What you stated is that this is a wrongful act. Therefore, your own logic supports the idea of molesting a child, and having sex without consent. So tell us, what makes you think it's okay to be such a perv?

[Minimalist]

Response: Amusing, when that was never stated. Yet what was clearly stated is the there is absolutely nothing wrong with consensual sex in marriage at puberty with someone who is mature. What you stated is that this is a wrongful act.

Interesting concept you have of "consensual."

http://www.foxnews.com/world/2010/04/10/...-says-mom/

A 13-year-old Yemeni child bride who bled to death shortly after marriage was tied down and forced to have sex by her husband, according to interviews with the child's mother, police and medical reports.

Over here, even known republicunt shithead Todd Akin might consider that a "legitimate rape." (Although with fundie xtians and you guys one can never be certain.)

[pocaracas]

Officer, they were asking for it... it's consensual. -.-'