Posts: 4196
Threads: 60
Joined: September 8, 2011
Reputation:
30
RE: Tentatively Christian; looking for a reasonable discussion
March 25, 2015 at 1:14 am
(March 24, 2015 at 9:50 pm)Nestor Wrote: And there is NOT an infinite amount of matter, as we know by the First Law of Thermodynamics. That is an assumption. If there is a star 100 billion light years away, we will not know for a while. No matter how many stars or galaxies we find, it cannot be proven that there is not one more. The theory of the 'Big Bang' suggests implicitly that matter may be infinite.
You make people miserable and there's nothing they can do about it, just like god.
-- Homer Simpson
God has no place within these walls, just as facts have no place within organized religion.
-- Superintendent Chalmers
Science is like a blabbermouth who ruins a movie by telling you how it ends. There are some things we don't want to know. Important things.
-- Ned Flanders
Once something's been approved by the government, it's no longer immoral.
-- The Rev Lovejoy
Posts: 23917
Threads: 300
Joined: June 25, 2011
Reputation:
150
RE: Tentatively Christian; looking for a reasonable discussion
March 25, 2015 at 1:22 am
In general it has always been a mistake to assume less where the cosmos is concerned. If bangs turn out to be a dime a dozen, then time may very well be infinite. At best the answer is probably not answerable without making assumption we can't support.
Posts: 8719
Threads: 128
Joined: March 1, 2012
Reputation:
53
RE: Tentatively Christian; looking for a reasonable discussion
March 25, 2015 at 8:20 am
(March 24, 2015 at 5:48 pm)Pizz-atheist Wrote: ...when we suspend belief in physcialism about the mind, the problem still stands. For example, mental states are anything but unchanging. One minute there is this thought and this experience, then the next minute there is another thought and experience, then two hours later there are different thoughts and experiences that are not identical(not to be confused with analogous) to ones from before...Another problem is that we can't find "I" in our thoughts and experiences. When "I" analysis the experience of sitting down and typing on a keyboard, into smaller parts "I" don't find an "I." Now, I common criticism to this is that the I is external to the thoughts and experiences. Okay, but this comes at a price; that is, the concept of Self would become a very sterile concept.
They are basically the same problem. Anyone, but Heraclitus, can see that from cradle to grave, Joe is still Joe. And anyone, except Parmenides, can see that Joe has changed in material composition, size shape, and capacities. I wish there was a philosophical tradition that could somehow resolve this dilemma. Hmmmmm....
Seriously though the experience of the higher Self is the profound experience of moving beyond the ego awareness of “I” and merging with the Divine. What to the ego appears to be a sterile concept turns out to feel very expansive and liberating.
Posts: 1164
Threads: 7
Joined: January 1, 2014
Reputation:
23
RE: Tentatively Christian; looking for a reasonable discussion
March 25, 2015 at 9:16 am
(March 25, 2015 at 8:20 am)Mezmo! Wrote: They are basically the same problem. Anyone, but Heraclitus, can see that from cradle to grave, Joe is still Joe. And anyone, except Parmenides, can see that Joe has changed in material composition, size shape, and capacities. I wish there was a philosophical tradition that could somehow resolve this dilemma. Hmmmmm....
Seriously though the experience of the higher Self is the profound experience of moving beyond the ego awareness of “I” and merging with the Divine. What to the ego appears to be a sterile concept turns out to feel very expansive and liberating.
Sure, him and Theseus, and everyone who notices that while Joe is asleep, Joe isn't Joe (at least the mind part, not the body which changes in a more chemically straightforward fashion.)
Or the split brain folks where Joe either can or can't find the word for chicken when shown a chicken depending on which eye it is shown to.
Or the people with dissociative identity disorder where Joe comes and goes and gets replaced by Ralph or Fred.
No, to the outside world, the thing that corresponds to Joe is the set of organized brain states which, by social convention, is recognized as 'Joe' when it is seen and recognized as 'Joe.' You might make an argument that from Joe's perspective, Joe always exists and it is reality that keeps coming and going. It's simpler and more consistent with observation for the rest of us to posit a continuous reality and an intermittent Joe. From outside Joe, all we can see is the brain states and try to understand how they interact to give Joe the sensation of being Joe.
Self aware neural networks are pretty easy to make: all that needs be done is to train one to recognize itself. This can be observed in the brain as input from the body is integrated and resolved into somatic markers which provide substrate on which to base decision making which is eventually reported to the conscious circuitry. The mystery of what is 'I' is being unpeeled for anyone who will see and accept that not being able to be someone else does not preclude understanding how that someone else can be constructed. Koch defined a set of rules by which contagious diseases could be attributed to specific causes: Koch's postulates. Application of these rules does not prove that the flu virus causes flu but it does give a framework on which to base decisions and actions as if it did. I expect there will, and probably soon, be a parallel but more complicated set of rules pertaining to observations of brain states which can similarly be used to define when a 'self' is there or not and whether that 'self' can be expected to return. At that point, philosophers discussing qualia, like those learned physicians who advocated the 'miasma theory' for the cause of cholera will have to shut up and die off.
So how, exactly, does God know that She's NOT a brain in a vat?
Posts: 8719
Threads: 128
Joined: March 1, 2012
Reputation:
53
RE: Tentatively Christian; looking for a reasonable discussion
March 25, 2015 at 10:11 am
(March 25, 2015 at 9:16 am)JuliaL Wrote: ...while Joe is asleep, Joe isn't Joe …the split…where Joe either can or can't find the word for chicken when shown a chicken depending on which eye it is shown to….[or] with dissociative identity disorder where Joe comes and goes and gets replaced by Ralph or Fred.
Indeed. Your examples all present interesting problems. Approaching these sorts of problems from a nominalist position, like you do, produces many paradoxes. I think one would first have to distinguish to what kind of universal does the particular instance, Joe, belong. It would seem to me Joe remains in essence human, and the personal ego identity, Joe, comes from accidental features.
(March 25, 2015 at 9:16 am)JuliaL Wrote: … the thing that corresponds to Joe is the set of organized brain states which, by social convention, is recognized as 'Joe' when it is seen and recognized as 'Joe. I guess that position kinda undermines the idea that Joe’s, or anyone else’s’, life can have meaning since Joe is nothing more than an arbitrary boundary between one socially determined* collection of material permutations and the rest of the material world.
(March 25, 2015 at 9:16 am)JuliaL Wrote: …Self-aware neural networks are pretty easy to make…at that point, philosophers discussing qualia, like those learned physicians who advocated the 'miasma theory' for the cause of cholera will have to shut up and die off. I think you bite off more than you can chew. The problems of qualia and intentionality would still remain unresolved. Besides, neo-Scholasticism doesn’t have the same kind of mind-body problem as modern analytic or continental philosophy.
*Which begs the question since the notion of a distinct social group is also an arbitrary boundary.
Posts: 5399
Threads: 256
Joined: December 1, 2013
Reputation:
60
RE: Tentatively Christian; looking for a reasonable discussion
March 25, 2015 at 10:42 am
(March 25, 2015 at 10:11 am)Mezmo! Wrote: I guess that position kinda undermines the idea that Joe’s, or anyone else’s’, life can have meaning since Joe is nothing more than an arbitrary boundary between one socially determined* collection of material permutations and the rest of the material world. Turns out "nothing more" is a sum of pretty incredible experiences to which the material permutations arbitrarily identified as the individual Joe assigns great value. Why do you assume more is required?
He who loves God cannot endeavour that God should love him in return - Baruch Spinoza
Posts: 1164
Threads: 7
Joined: January 1, 2014
Reputation:
23
RE: Tentatively Christian; looking for a reasonable discussion
March 25, 2015 at 10:43 am
(This post was last modified: March 25, 2015 at 10:53 am by JuliaL.)
So how, exactly, does God know that She's NOT a brain in a vat?
Posts: 2082
Threads: 72
Joined: March 12, 2013
Reputation:
44
RE: Tentatively Christian; looking for a reasonable discussion
March 25, 2015 at 12:33 pm
(This post was last modified: March 25, 2015 at 12:38 pm by The Reality Salesman01.)
Posts: 11260
Threads: 61
Joined: January 5, 2013
Reputation:
123
RE: Tentatively Christian; looking for a reasonable discussion
March 25, 2015 at 1:48 pm
(March 25, 2015 at 8:20 am)Mezmo! Wrote: They are basically the same problem. Anyone, but Heraclitus, can see that from cradle to grave, Joe is still Joe. And anyone, except Parmenides, can see that Joe has changed in material composition, size shape, and capacities. I wish there was a philosophical tradition that could somehow resolve this dilemma. Hmmmmm....
There's also a realistic tradition that resolves this dilemma, by revealing that the dilemma is merely an equivocation offered by people wishing to resort to the philosophical tradition; Joe may have changed in material composition, but he has not done so entirely, all at once. Joe changes gradually over time, and since "Joe," as an identity,exists as a process going on within Joe's brain, that process can persist regardless of how many physical things change. Sort of like how I can replace the fan on my PC, yet the hard drive doesn't require magic to retain all its programs just because a physical component changes.
"YOU take the hard look in the mirror. You are everything that is wrong with this world. The only thing important to you, is you." - ronedee
Want to see more of my writing? Check out my (safe for work!) site, Unprotected Sects!
Posts: 1114
Threads: 28
Joined: June 13, 2011
Reputation:
18
RE: Tentatively Christian; looking for a reasonable discussion
March 25, 2015 at 1:54 pm
Maybe we should be Software-Hardware dualists?
It is very important not to mistake hemlock for parsley, but to believe or not believe in God is not important at all. - Denis Diderot
We are the United States of Amnesia, we learn nothing because we remember nothing. - Gore Vidal
|