Judge orders child removed from Lesbian couple's care

[brewer]

[Chad32]

The fight still goes on to treat homosexuals fairly. Unfortunately I'm not sure how long it will take before people get over this, because some people still haven't gotten over the fact that non white people should have the same rights and priviledges as white people.

This issue of caring for children is likely about to get more heated since gay marriage is legal now.

[rexbeccarox]

This is SO effed up. DCFS and the bio mother want this couple to raise the baby. How has it gotten to the point where church/state separation is no longer a thing, and a judge can use a debunked study (one that only includes two effing gay couples) in order to rip a family apart? How is this judge still on the bench, even?

I do have to say that I'm happily surprised by the comment section on the article, though. I didn't come across one person supporting the judge's decision, and we're talking about Utah. I see that as a small amount of progress, at least.

[Regina]

Well considering he didn't even provide evidence for this "research" it shouldn't have happened.

Meanwhile, I hope that little girl has a happy childhood parentless in an adoption home. Nice fucking move asshole.

[Chad32]

It was a slow creep over time, I'm sure. A little change here, and a little change there, until this country is so close to a theocracy that people don't know that you're not supposed to pass laws dictated by the bible, and that the founders were trying to make a christian theocracy.

[robvalue]

God damn it. This is such bollocks!

Even if there was any truth to the claim that homosexual couples are worse parents (and I don't believe it for a second), it's fucking irrelevant when you have the actual people in front of you to assess.

Profiling.

Obviously he's a fuck face bigot and he's trying to twist the facts to justify his sordid agenda. People so ignorant should be the judge of nothing.

[brewer]

[The Valkyrie]

Do they have any legal recourse to demand a non bigoted judge, to demand that he provides his evidence, or to sue him?

[robvalue]

They bloody well should have! I really hope so.

What if the judge announced people with black hair are worse parents, and took a kid away citing some garbage a loony had written?

[TheRealJoeFish]

This should be and will be overturned quite quickly, I think. From a legal standpoint, a judge saying "couples in class A are better for children than couples in class B; therefore, *any* couple in class A is better than *this* couple in class B" is, in addition to being idiotic, a deprivation of due process rights, because the couple was judged by the class they belonged to rather than their particular circumstances, which I am quite sure is against Utah law. It's also almost word for word the definition of prejudice.