Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: March 28, 2024, 9:10 am

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
#21
RE: Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
(December 15, 2016 at 6:15 am)Alex K Wrote: iow, I propose that all logically consistent and well defined notions of free will are compatible with determinism.

In what sense is it free?

(December 15, 2016 at 6:10 am)Alex K Wrote: I don't think free will in the way you would like to have it can exist at all, to me, it doesn't really figure into the equation whether the universe is deterministic or not.

Also, even if the universe is not deterministic, that does not mean it's free.   It also does not mean there truly is any sort of will.  It merely mean more than one outcome is possible provided one define what constitute an outcome specifically enough.   The notional unpredictable dice has no free will.

For me, the closest approximation to an empirical definition of free will would be if the possessor of free will can uniquely reduce the number of possible outcomes in a particular situation in a way he alone could demonstrably predict, and yet there is no other agent whosoever who could even theoretically Possess the capability to predict how the possessor of the free will would reduce these possible outcomes.

If the possessor of the so called free will can not predict his will a priori, then He can not demonstrate any will, only ex post claim of control over what he had really demonstrated no control over.
Reply
#22
RE: Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
Yes I agree. A choice is truly free if its outcome cannot be predicted. Even by a "God". That is why it's at odds with precognition of any kind.

I mean, if God wants to entertain itself, why the hell would it create a load of stuff that it knows the outcome of? What fun is that?

(December 15, 2016 at 8:50 am)RozKek Wrote:
(December 15, 2016 at 7:10 am)robvalue Wrote: It doesn't, at all. It's just obfuscation.

And thanks very much! I got plenty more where that came from Tongue


I'm not sure what you're saying here. If we're discussing hard determinism, as in everything could be predicted from the word go, then I don't see any kind of "free will" being possible, that means anything.

By "free will", I would mean that intelligent agents have a genuine choice of multiple actions, and they could actually choose any of them. If it can be predicted what the agent will do with complete accuracy, then I no longer see it as any kind of choice. It's just a sequence of causes and effects. All we have is the illusion of choice.

If you define "choice"/"free will" so that it covers no real choice at all, then it's compatible, but meaningless IMO.

I agree completely with this, and I just want to add, even if the universe isn't superdeterministic and there is true randomness, I don't think free will exists in that case either. You have no control over true randomness the same way one has no control over something already determined. But it isn't 'either you're determined or driven by randomness' because the brain isn't quantum and follows cause and effect. Iow the brain is deterministic.

I've met definitions of free will where they've restricted free will to merely acting according to ones intentions with no restrictions from an outside force, in this case outside force being an agent; agent being another person. I don't agree with that definition because our will is clearly affected and determined by literally everything else, not just agents but by how the universe behaves and what we are. Why exclude that fact? Another thing is regarding acting out of your intention with no agent holding a gun to your head, what your intention is isn't your choice nor is they way you decide to approach your intention your choice, it's all determined and that renders that definition of free will pretty much useless. Our will is free when our intention and the way we act according to our intention isn't random nor determined an I don't see that being the case. Right now the only free wills we have are definitions of it that don't take into account things that play a quite big role. Just thought I'd bring this up, since I've seen it discussed.

I agree. It seems there is no evidence to suggest anything other than simple randomness being at the heart of any "choices". So it's really just flowery language to suggest that a living thing, as a whole, is making a "choice". What we really have is our conscious mind telling us stories about our choices, that we don't have any proper control over. We're a slave to our surroundings, our past, and randomness, so it would seem.

Experiments already suggest we don't "make" choices at the time that we think they do, they can be made far earlier without us realizing it.

(December 15, 2016 at 7:58 am)purplepurpose Wrote:
(December 15, 2016 at 7:15 am)robvalue Wrote: I don't think it's voluntarily. It's indoctrinated into them, on the whole. They can't simply discard it. It takes a huge feat of bravery to challenge the beliefs, and eventually work through them to the point where they can be discounted.
If your talking about belief, where your ordered to kill people in the Gods name, that's fairly easy, especially if your promised heaven if you die. You take a part in a successful conquest - you will be rewarded. You die- rewarded. That's easy to believe in.

But, if we are talking about belief, where you must strive to be more selfless, even if your fed an idea of hell for refusing it, it sounds f hard, because its valuable, even if indoctrination is in the mix.

Atheism is "soft" compared to the idea of "selfless or burn".

It's no so much "selfless or burn" as "follow this massive arbitrary list of rules or burn". Reducing religious doctrine to being selfless is oversimplifying in most cases.

But either way, yes I agree. Having the mental burden of a possible "hell" hanging over you must be absolutely horrible. I feel very sorry for anyone who believes such a thing is real. It isn't, obviously, but things are as real as they seem, to each person. I wish I could save people from this horrific mental torture.

So indeed, I am massively unburdened in that regard. My worries are only for this life, and not beyond it. Knowing that when I die I am done and dusted is comforting to me. Some people might find that odd I suppose. For me it's just facing reality. There's nothing to be scared of.

Atheists don't necessarily disbelieve in hell, although probably the vast majority do. I've met at least one who still believes in it, at least enough to be upset about it.
Feel free to send me a private message.
Please visit my website here! It's got lots of information about atheism/theism and support for new atheists.

Index of useful threads and discussions
Index of my best videos
Quickstart guide to the forum
Reply
#23
RE: Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
(December 14, 2016 at 11:42 pm)operator Wrote: I would like to have some theists explain to me how fate and free will can coexist?

Clearly many theists believe that since god is all knowing, our fates are predetermined. God already knows what we will do, how we will do it, whether or not we will change our minds, what we think and what we will think in the future. God knows all because he created all and we cannot escape his ultimate knowledge of everything.

Yet...

Many theists also believe we have free will, and that this of course explains why humans can be evil or do bad things. We can choose to do as we please, when we want and how we want. We are the sole authors of our own actions and we are in control of what we do and think.

My question is, how can these two things coexist? How do we have free will if god already knows what we're going to do? God has already laid out the plan for our lives, so how can we choose to do anything? How can we even choose to believe in him or at least follow him, even skeptically, when he has already predetermined some of us to be atheists?

Isn't this akin to locking someone in a cell, placing a can of Pepsi and a can of Coke in front of them and saying, "You have the free will to choose to do whatever you like,"?

Maybe I'm missing something here.

Atheists, obviously, can also chime in. I'm interested to hear everyone's thoughts.

It depends on how you view God's control over creation.

If you do so biblically then it's important to note that the bible never makes a freewill claim. That was a greek philosophy that was added some centuries later. The bible says we are all slaves to sin, meaning our will is tied to sin. Thereby being far from free. However we have been given a single choice to make if we so choose to make. That is to serve God or to serve sin. If we choose to serve God then once we die sin no longer has control over us. Allowing God to resurrect us to service to Him.

Is this the greek philosophy of free will that the church has adapted? No. Is this the cliche 18th century southern plantation owner/slave relationship? Again no.

We have been given choices to make in God's plan.
Reply
#24
RE: Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
To the OP, the a question cannot be answered apart from having a theory of time of which there are at least three: presentism, eternalism, and block theory. I have not committed to any particular philosophical position. Likewise, I am not convinced that natural science will ever be able to offer an adequate explanation since its necessary assumptions, like causal closure, operate within time. As for the Holy Scriptures, they appear to be neutral on the question. A couple of verses by Saint Paul are suggestive but that's about it;
Reply
#25
RE: Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
Catholic_Lady Wrote:Knowing what we will choose to do bc he has seen the future =/= predetermined fate

Say, the Lord has seen me eat ice-cream tomorrow noon at around 12. Do I have the ability to eat a chicken roll instead or will I have to strictly stick with the ice-cream?
Reply
#26
RE: Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
(December 15, 2016 at 10:27 am)pool the great Wrote:
Catholic_Lady Wrote:Knowing what we will choose to do bc he has seen the future =/= predetermined fate

Say, the Lord has seen me eat ice-cream tomorrow noon at around 12. Do I have the ability to eat a chicken roll instead or will I have to strictly stick with the ice-cream?

What? Not sure if this is a serious question. Obviously you can choose to eat whatever you want. The point is He already knows what you will choose because he's already seen it happen.
"Of course, everyone will claim they respect someone who tries to speak the truth, but in reality, this is a rare quality. Most respect those who speak truths they agree with, and their respect for the speaking only extends as far as their realm of personal agreement. It is less common, almost to the point of becoming a saintly virtue, that someone truly respects and loves the truth seeker, even when their conclusions differ wildly." 

-walsh
Reply
#27
RE: Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
(December 15, 2016 at 10:31 am)Catholic_Lady Wrote:
(December 15, 2016 at 10:27 am)pool the great Wrote: Say, the Lord has seen me eat ice-cream tomorrow noon at around 12. Do I have the ability to eat a chicken roll instead or will I have to strictly stick with the ice-cream?

What? Not sure if this is a serious question. Obviously you can choose to eat whatever you want. The point is He already knows what you will choose because he's already seen it happen.

If by some miracle Jesus let's me know what I will have for breakfast tomorrow, will I have a chance on changing it?
Reply
#28
RE: Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
(December 15, 2016 at 10:38 am)pool the great Wrote:
(December 15, 2016 at 10:31 am)Catholic_Lady Wrote: What? Not sure if this is a serious question. Obviously you can choose to eat whatever you want. The point is He already knows what you will choose because he's already seen it happen.

If by some miracle Jesus let's me know what I will have for breakfast tomorrow, will I have a chance on changing it?

Sure. But he would already have seen that.
"Of course, everyone will claim they respect someone who tries to speak the truth, but in reality, this is a rare quality. Most respect those who speak truths they agree with, and their respect for the speaking only extends as far as their realm of personal agreement. It is less common, almost to the point of becoming a saintly virtue, that someone truly respects and loves the truth seeker, even when their conclusions differ wildly." 

-walsh
Reply
#29
RE: Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
(December 15, 2016 at 10:39 am)Catholic_Lady Wrote:
(December 15, 2016 at 10:38 am)pool the great Wrote: If by some miracle Jesus let's me know what I will have for breakfast tomorrow, will I have a chance on changing it?

Sure. But he would already have seen that.

Let's say Jesus let's me know that I'll have steak tomorrow. Then I choose to have juice instead tomorrow. Does this mean Jesus lied? Isn't he not allowed to commit sin? So he'll have to tell me truthfully that I'll have steak tomorrow but my question is - do I have a say on this or not, ie, will I be forced to eat steak or choose for myself?
Reply
#30
RE: Theists: How can predetermined fate and free will coexist?
Sure, Jesus lied then. He either didn't really know the future, or he was telling you a fake version.

It doesn't really matter who has the knowledge. It's just a matter of whether it's possible for there to be such knowledge of the outcome of a choice before it is made. If it's possible, then it's not a real choice.

God shouting out, "I knew that would happen" is not that impressive. I can do that too.
Feel free to send me a private message.
Please visit my website here! It's got lots of information about atheism/theism and support for new atheists.

Index of useful threads and discussions
Index of my best videos
Quickstart guide to the forum
Reply



Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  A thing about religious (and other) people and the illusion of free will ShinyCrystals 265 10894 December 6, 2023 at 12:21 am
Last Post: Harry Haller
  If god can't lie, does that mean he can't do everything? Foxaèr 184 10610 September 10, 2021 at 4:20 pm
Last Post: Dundee
  Is God weaker than theists imagine, and is mankind stronger? invalid 6 2326 March 5, 2021 at 6:38 am
Last Post: arewethereyet
  Should Theists have the burden of proof at the police and court? Vast Vision 16 5181 July 10, 2017 at 1:34 pm
Last Post: Jesster
  God and theists. WinterHold 96 32999 May 23, 2017 at 12:13 pm
Last Post: Crossless2.0
  Good theists... Parts 1 and 2 merged ScienceAf 72 10574 October 12, 2016 at 2:21 pm
Last Post: Kingpin
  what do non/anti-religion Deists and Theists believe ? jenny1972 94 13808 November 17, 2015 at 11:52 am
Last Post: drfuzzy
  Theists: Can god read my mind? robvalue 27 6358 July 25, 2015 at 8:47 am
Last Post: ignoramus
  Can I be sued for saving someone's life? Yes I can Dystopia 25 5200 July 14, 2015 at 5:47 pm
Last Post: Jackalope
  What do the theists here think about masturbation and porn? rado84 177 31576 July 13, 2015 at 1:33 pm
Last Post: Catholic_Lady



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)