(October 19, 2015 at 11:32 am)JBrentonK Wrote: Thankfully God is not a non existing proposition.

Feels like you've gotta do more than just assert that, champ.

(October 19, 2015 at 11:25 am)Alex K Wrote: I prefer 80 proof,  but other atheists may disagree.

I'm more athy that you.

(October 19, 2015 at 11:22 am)Esquilax Wrote: So, am I the only one who thinks this guy is using some weird, arcane other definition for, like, every term he's using here?  

How about Occam's Razor?   Maybe he's just a fuckhead?

OP as fuckhead is the most parsimonious explanation fitting all the facts.

I'm the most number 1 atheist contributive. However; I believe I am an atheist. But am I an atheist? Yes, proof. Then again, I'm an atheist only to the utmost number 1. Proof? However; yes.

How about this:

Why should I care if there is a god?

Absolutely. My life is incomplete if I cannot justify myself to every internet fuckwad that comes down the line.

(October 19, 2015 at 11:42 am)Exian Wrote: I'm the most number 1 atheist contributive. However; I believe I am an atheist. But am I an atheist? Yes, proof. Then again, I'm an atheist only to the utmost number 1. Proof? However; yes.

Indeed, the soliloquy of the atheist position is daft, whilst simultaneously enriching, don't you think? If number 1 is the loneliest number, what does that say about 2, or even 3? 

Contributive <> combative! Words to the wise in my sight. If cheese were a vegetable, would a vegan still be able to eat it?

JBrentonK Wrote:I believe that you do not believe in God, can not be contributive, cannot base your beliefs on your acts and can not act positively as a result. You cannot give to charity (or at least I wouldn't want you to), you cannot base your beliefs on the faith in your beliefs which beg for your positive contribution to the world. The world begs you for love.   Give it or else!

What would you think of someone who insisted that you don't really think what you say you think? How does it follow from not believing in God that one cannot give to charity (Google atheist charity if you doubt we give to them).

I snipped the rest of your OP, which was even more salad-y than this bit.

Esquilax Wrote:

JBrentonK Wrote:Thankfully God is not a non existing proposition.

Feels like you've gotta do more than just assert that, champ.

Well, the proposition exists.