Quote:Please, define a "false dilemma fallacy.

Why would you need me to define a fallacy your throwing around ?

Quote: while."

I don't know how old you are, but 23 years is not a long time and you will realize that at some point; "gender dysphoria," one of several subcategories that "Gender Identity Disorder" (the 1980 academic definition of transgenderism and related mental disorders) once covered before being broken into those subcategories in 2013 still remains in the DSM-5.

I keep on mentioning the DSM-5 and previous editions, so just to be clear - the Diagnostic and Statistic Manual of Mental Disorders (Vol. 5), published by the American Psychiatric Association, still lists all the various aspects of transgenderism as mental disorders; they just don't label it as "GID" anymore.

---

I am aware one does not need to be intersex to be trans; that has been a fundamental aspect of my argument, that the majority of transexual individuals are not intersex.


"Period" is not an argument, nor are either unintentional misrepresentations of my statements by unbelievable hyperbolic measures nor the potential strawman arguments achieving the same.

You are arguing an anti-scientific position, and it's why I can come in here with sources, references, citations and the best I can get is insults and logical fallacies.

Nah all you can come up with is ignorance and nonesense your the only one going against science buddy and once again no fallacies to be found.

Your awful at this 

Also, while we’re on the changes to the DSM-5, here’s the testimony of someone who was actually on the DSM panel for that specific issue.

TL;DR: the way the previous editions of the DSM talked about “Gender identity disorder” was fundamentally at odds with how it actually worked.

(November 21, 2024 at 5:53 pm)Rev. Rye Wrote:

(November 21, 2024 at 5:45 pm)TheWhiteMarten Wrote: Please, define a "false dilemma fallacy."

So, you’re asking for a definition of the phrase you yourself used.

(November 21, 2024 at 5:36 pm)TheWhiteMarten Wrote: False dilemma fallacy. 

This is basically trolling by this point.

Was he ever not ? 

You can't make arguments as bad as his and be serious 

(November 21, 2024 at 6:01 pm)Rev. Rye Wrote: Also, while we’re on the changes to the DSM-5, here’s  the testimony of someone who was actually on the DSM panel for that specific issue.

TL;DR: the way the previous editions of the DSM talked about “Gender identity disorder” was fundamentally at odds with how it actually worked.

Yup makes excellent distinctions

(November 21, 2024 at 5:50 pm)Rev. Rye Wrote: Where is the false dilemma here? You stated, and, I quote:

"Either you're mighty forgetful, or dishonest. Which is it?"

(November 21, 2024 at 5:54 pm)The Architect Of Fate Wrote:

Quote:Please, define a "false dilemma fallacy.

Why would you need me to define a fallacy your throwing around ?

Oh come on, you sure have a lot to say from the sidelines but turn mighty red when asked to perform yourself.

What is a false dilemma fallacy?

I'm not asking for the same courtesy I have provided yall and ask you to cite which dictionary or encyclopedia you want to define it from, just give me a colloquial and simple definition.

(November 21, 2024 at 6:01 pm)Rev. Rye Wrote: Also, while we’re on the changes to the DSM-5, here’s  the testimony of someone who was actually on the DSM panel for that specific issue.

TL;DR: the way the previous editions of the DSM talked about “Gender identity disorder” was fundamentally at odds with how it actually worked.

Ah, a random Quora poster. Seems legit.


Should I start posting from Reddit instead of citing actual organizations and professionals as well?

Edit - and all it does is essentially state that "Gender Dysphoria" was broken up into multiple pieces to more accurately describe the mental disorders.... oof.

It's almost like what I've been saying all along... it stopped being a "disorder" in itself and instead became a bunch of lesser disorders...

Quote:Ah, a random Quora poster. Seems legit.

Actually by content 

Quote:Should I start posting from Reddit instead of citing actual organizations and professionals as well?

Nah everything you'll post is garbage but it won't be all that much different then what you post anyway 

Quote:Edit - and all it does is essentially state that "Gender Dysphoria" was broken up into multiple pieces to more accurately describe the mental disorders.... oof.

Actually it doesn't

Quote:It's almost like what I've been saying all along... it stopped being a "disorder" in itself and instead became a bunch of lesser disorders...

Nope like with everything else you mouth off about you are wrong.

(November 21, 2024 at 6:07 pm)TheWhiteMarten Wrote:

(November 21, 2024 at 5:50 pm)Rev. Rye Wrote: Where is the false dilemma here? You stated, and, I quote:

"Either you're mighty forgetful, or dishonest. Which is it?"

You make a claim, and then, once called on it, deny actually making said claim. What is the possible third option? Iranian superhackers Managed to tamper with your post without even registering a “this post was last modified by”?