Posts: 5022
Threads: 13
Joined: September 27, 2018
Reputation:
16
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
November 13, 2026 at 6:25 am
(November 12, 2026 at 7:37 am)emjay Wrote: At the end of the day, I've always considered Biblical 'non-literalism' an unstructured/illogical cop-out, but this book feels anything but that... it feels very logical, very structured, and very good psychology... and if what you're saying is that generally speaking much classical theology thinks/talks like this, then I accept it's my bad for not paying enough attention to it.
I admit I'm at a disadvantage in knowing what rank-and-file Christianity is like for people in English-speaking countries. I was raised completely without religion, and have never once attended a church service -- even a wedding or a funeral in a church. My introduction to Christianity (other than Christmas carols on the radio) was a class on Dante in college. So I sort of started at the top, and didn't have to make an effort to reject the simpler version that many people seem to have heard as children.
I've been told that the kind of theology I'm interested in is obscure or irrelevant to Christianity as it's really practiced, but the people whose books I read, whose blogs I look at, whose Tweets I see -- all of these people take the classical theology as the norm.
Quote:It feels to me, that this makes far more logical sense than taking the Bible at face value... necessarily at least.... as literal claims and nothing but. I never thought that would make sense to me, because I think in black and white terms more often than not, but here in this book it gives clear arguments for why a non-literal interpretation makes far more logical sense than a literal one in many cases. So in other words, I can still be black and white/literally minded about it, but accepting a flipped switch, so to speak, in what the intent was in the writing... which it seems to be arguing that it, that writing intent, more often than not is non-literal, and sometimes it is both non-literal and literal.
That's exactly right, I think. The Bible was written by different people at different times for different reasons, and operates at all different levels. To know which part is meant how, we basically have to sit down with the best scholarship and work on it. Some people want it to be easy, but I don't see why things have to be obvious.
Quote:I mean obviously regardless of literary intent, ie literal or non-literal writing intent, it's still people writing and making claims, so still open to controversy on that score, but this does nonetheless allow me to change how I view what is actually being claimed, to something that, currently at least, makes far more logical sense to me than 'face value' alone does.
Yeah, I hope I don't give the impression that I think all of this has been definitively proven, or that everybody has to accept it. Every single claim has been debated pretty much forever. Jumping into the tradition means entering the debate. What I've read of Nicoll so far is fairly uncontroversial within the tradition, but it's true that Jung, Gurdjieff, and Ouspensky had some variations of their own which may seem pretty kooky to the rest of us.
Quote:I would disagree with it though if it's going to the length of claiming that man begins at a negative extreme... ie pure evil or totally selfish etc by nature and only free-able from that by this... that I would disagree with because in my opinion, that's blatantly not the case; 'selfless' compassion and empathy exists anywhere and everywhere regardless of all this sort of thing, at least some of the time... but if it's not going to that extreme... or if it is going to that extreme, me not taking it to that extreme... then at a less extreme level I think it makes good logical and psychological sense as something to aim for, and in that regard, does seem to have some parallels with Buddhism... similar perhaps to its active 'development' of compassion and 'selflessness' kind of thing... so who knows, maybe that could be what my Buddhist friend sees in it. In any case though, I don't see any problem in perhaps merging the psychological ideas of it with Buddhist ideas, which again might be the sort of approach my Buddhist friend is taking. Hopefully I'll find out, when I next talk to him, hopefully next week.
This is an interesting topic. How bad are we in our native untrained condition? Obviously the doctrine of Original Sin starts us off bad, but Dante argues (like Rousseau) that in our most natural state we desire the Good without complication. It's society, or bad training, or bad habits, that get us off track. More recent philosophers have denied that people have a "natural essence" or "human nature," so talking about what we would be like in the absence of influences doesn't make sense. We are wrapped up in a culture from before we're even born, so how much we have to get over, or how much self-love we have to un-train from ourselves depends a lot on contingencies or time and place.
As for Nud's assertion that Nicoll was "a guy who blew up his life after meeting a cult leader and then spent some amount of time trying to sanitize and christianize what he'd learned at the cult compound" that's the most prejudiced, slanted, uncharitable way to describe what happened. He didn't "blow up" his life. He decided to stop practicing psychiatry on Harley Street and devote his time to his spiritual studies. He didn't sell all his possessions or leave his family or do anything that constitutes a blow up. He moved with his family to Gurdjieff’s Institute for the Harmonious Development of Man, a former priory in a beautiful part of France, famous for its landscape painters. The institute operated very much like Buddhist retreats. Members and visitors did physical labor, not because they were enslaved but because working with your hands is a part of being grounded. Gurdjieff emphasized conscious effort over mere drudgery: one stone moved with attention was worth a pile moved mechanically. So: mindfulness during productive, physical action. This was not a Jonestown-type situation where the guru was taking advantage of people. Claiming him as the "poster boy" for "harmful and damaging belief" is not something the facts can support.
Even if we argue that Nicoll was an imperfect individual (as everyone is), the tradition of which he was a part is very valuable. Wikipedia lists his influences as Neoplatonism, Gnosticism, Hermeticism, Alchemy, Sufism, Greek philosophy, Jakob Böhme, and William Blake, among others. Someone who spent a semester on each of these subjects would end up a wiser and better person. (I really should do it.)
Posts: 69309
Threads: 140
Joined: June 28, 2011
Reputation:
161
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
November 13, 2026 at 9:46 am
You can tell it's not a cult compound because the drapes are nice and the real estate is prime, lol.
I am the Infantry. I am my country’s strength in war, her deterrent in peace. I am the heart of the fight… wherever, whenever. I carry America’s faith and honor against her enemies. I am the Queen of Battle. I am what my country expects me to be, the best trained Soldier in the world. In the race for victory, I am swift, determined, and courageous, armed with a fierce will to win. Never will I fail my country’s trust. Always I fight on…through the foe, to the objective, to triumph overall. If necessary, I will fight to my death. By my steadfast courage, I have won more than 200 years of freedom. I yield not to weakness, to hunger, to cowardice, to fatigue, to superior odds, For I am mentally tough, physically strong, and morally straight. I forsake not, my country, my mission, my comrades, my sacred duty. I am relentless. I am always there, now and forever. I AM THE INFANTRY! FOLLOW ME!
Posts: 10525
Threads: 31
Joined: April 3, 2015
Reputation:
64
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
November 13, 2026 at 10:29 am
(This post was last modified: November 13, 2026 at 11:13 am by emjay.)
(November 13, 2026 at 6:25 am)Belacqua Wrote: (November 12, 2026 at 7:37 am)emjay Wrote: At the end of the day, I've always considered Biblical 'non-literalism' an unstructured/illogical cop-out, but this book feels anything but that... it feels very logical, very structured, and very good psychology... and if what you're saying is that generally speaking much classical theology thinks/talks like this, then I accept it's my bad for not paying enough attention to it.
I admit I'm at a disadvantage in knowing what rank-and-file Christianity is like for people in English-speaking countries. I was raised completely without religion, and have never once attended a church service -- even a wedding or a funeral in a church. My introduction to Christianity (other than Christmas carols on the radio) was a class on Dante in college. So I sort of started at the top, and didn't have to make an effort to reject the simpler version that many people seem to have heard as children.
I've been told that the kind of theology I'm interested in is obscure or irrelevant to Christianity as it's really practiced, but the people whose books I read, whose blogs I look at, whose Tweets I see -- all of these people take the classical theology as the norm.
[...]
In my family's case, me and my dad I'd say are very similar in our 'literal/ist' approach to the Bible, and I'd go as far as saying I think there's a fair chance my dad's just as much on the autistic spectrum as I consider myself, in terms of literalism and black and white thinking, and everything else that goes with it. Have you heard of anyone else creating a spreadsheet specifically to tell them exactly what to wear based on the predicted or measured temperatures outside on any and every given day? (BTW... I asked and he's fine with me talking about that... he's proud of it  ) So when someone gave him a mug for his birthday that said 'I [heart] spreadsheets' that was the understatement of the year  I'm similar, but with databases rather than spreadsheets
So the irony here is that my dad's black and white thinking means, in my opinion (could be wrong, but I don't think so), that even if I did accept this sort of classical theism, he wouldn't accept me for that... no more than he would if I became a Catholic (he being a Protestant), or as I am, an atheist, or a Buddhist. In other words, it's all about having the right interpretation to him, which he thinks he has... which everybody thinks they have... and that's the second irony; that this book is largely about that, about the attachment lets say to 'lower' knowledge leading to all this sort of division and schisms in the world... millions of different interpretations... tower of Babel kind of thing. So yeah, it's very ironic that this kind of addresses that sort of issue, similar, maybe, or at least a little, to Buddhism's 'third herd of deer' which is all about overcoming attachment to ideas.
Anyway, back to earth a minute  In the UK I've personally never met anyone that talks about classical theology, in all my growing up experience of Christianity... but that's just the environment I grew up in.... largely 'Baptist' and 'Pentecostal' churches. I have no idea if there is a different, large classical theist presence in the country, but I've personally never seen it... but each to their own, and each has their own 'norm'.
I think ultimately the only way my dad could possibly break out of an extremely literalist view, like we both have, would be similar to what I just worked out... that the 'writing intent' could be different... ie that just essentially flips one switch... but doesn't affect our black and white/logical nature. Maybe worth aiming for, because I think it would be an upgrade  Maybe I should try and get him to read this book
I might reply to the rest of the post some other time, but for now, this seems enough
Posts: 69309
Threads: 140
Joined: June 28, 2011
Reputation:
161
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
November 13, 2026 at 10:35 am
The mystical and esoteric gospels - the ones where "the writing intent" was different...were shitcanned. They're apocrypha. That was actually one of the first internal disputes christianity solved.
I am the Infantry. I am my country’s strength in war, her deterrent in peace. I am the heart of the fight… wherever, whenever. I carry America’s faith and honor against her enemies. I am the Queen of Battle. I am what my country expects me to be, the best trained Soldier in the world. In the race for victory, I am swift, determined, and courageous, armed with a fierce will to win. Never will I fail my country’s trust. Always I fight on…through the foe, to the objective, to triumph overall. If necessary, I will fight to my death. By my steadfast courage, I have won more than 200 years of freedom. I yield not to weakness, to hunger, to cowardice, to fatigue, to superior odds, For I am mentally tough, physically strong, and morally straight. I forsake not, my country, my mission, my comrades, my sacred duty. I am relentless. I am always there, now and forever. I AM THE INFANTRY! FOLLOW ME!
Posts: 10525
Threads: 31
Joined: April 3, 2015
Reputation:
64
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
November 13, 2026 at 10:56 am
(November 13, 2026 at 10:35 am)The Grand Nudger Wrote: The mystical and esoteric gospels - the ones where "the writing intent" was different...were shitcanned. They're apocrypha. That was actually one of the first internal disputes christianity solved.
Right, well if you don't tell him (my dad) it was 'shitcanned', I won't  As I said, it still seems like an upgrade... so if that switch could flip in me, maybe it could in him as well  Ie so far, there's nothing, at least obviously, bigoted about this book... which is a massive upgrade from the usual bigotry that comes from literalist Christianity. In other words, I'd much rather he was interested in this type of Christianity than the type he is interested in... not to say that he's a bad person or anything, he's not, but there are literalist barriers we'll never get past unless we have a different view of what is being claimed in the first place.
Posts: 44
Threads: 2
Joined: November 5, 2026
Reputation:
0
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
November 13, 2026 at 1:01 pm
(November 13, 2026 at 10:35 am)The Grand Nudger Wrote: The mystical and esoteric gospels - the ones where "the writing intent" was different...were shitcanned. They're apocrypha. That was actually one of the first internal disputes christianity solved.
The apocrypha - some of which I have read, and others not - can be interesting, of course, to complete the picture, and sometimes also to give clues as to how unclear statements of the bible could be made sense of within the hebrew tradition as a whole. The Gospel of Thomas that I did read is according to some scholars likely to be the oldest account of the Jesus character.
In general I would discourage people from turning to books in hope of discovering the perfect spirituality or anything like that. Spirituality, in my opinion, can to a large extent only be hinted at. And I also do not think that The Gospel of Thomas or other apocrypha that I have looked into will solve much for those who are not happy with the bible. For me, they most certainly did not, and that is also why I did not bother to read all of the Nag Hammadi texts, for example. If one is into any kind of deep reality then I do think that there is better literature, but then again, texts are not a necessity for spirituality at all. My experience is that, yeah, reading a really good book can help you in some ways. But mostly, what I experienced from reading is that it helped me dispel false ideas that had been planted by various authorities and proselytizers, and not that it actually led me to depths of spirituality. On a few rare occasions, reading someone who attempted the impossible - to put in print something about deep reality - served to help me confirm that things I already experienced made a lot more sense than I had had the strength to assert on my own, but now I am not at all talking about the hebrew tradition. Other traditions were more useful. The most helpful were those extremely odd and truly rare modern commentators who obviously did not care much about pleasing anyone, but only about writing something that is worthwhile in and of itself. That could amount to pleasing the genuine seeker, but not academia, not church, not state, not party, not friends and relatives. I will not share what those were, however, for more than one reason. On the one hand, what was useful to me may not be useful to you. On the other hand, I am not in agreement even with those authors, and so, I think that it depends also on where the reader focuses if he will be edified or not.
A third reason not to share is of course that it is off topic. Sorry for going off on a tangent, but it began with the apocrypha that should not be ignored in the scientific effort to make sense of the new testament. They ought to be studied more than I did for the purpose of getting a more complete picture, scientifically.
Then the Pharisees and scribes asked Him, “Why walk not thy disciples according to the tradition of the elders, but eat bread with unwashed hands?” He answered and said unto them, “Well hath Isaiah prophesied of you hypocrites, as it is written: ‘This people honoreth Me with their lips, but their heart is far from Me. Therefore, in vain do they worship Me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.’ For laying aside the commandment of God, ye hold to the tradition of men, as the washing of pots and cups, and many other like things ye do.” And He said unto them, “Full well ye reject the commandment of God, that ye may keep your own tradition. For Moses said, ‘Honor thy father and thy mother,’ and, ‘Whoso curseth father or mother, let him die the death.’ (Mark 7:5-10)
Posts: 5022
Threads: 13
Joined: September 27, 2018
Reputation:
16
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
November 14, 2026 at 12:12 am
(November 13, 2026 at 1:01 pm)Dao Wrote: (November 13, 2026 at 10:35 am)The Grand Nudger Wrote: The mystical and esoteric gospels - the ones where "the writing intent" was different...were shitcanned. They're apocrypha. That was actually one of the first internal disputes christianity solved.
The apocrypha - some of which I have read, and others not - can be interesting, of course, to complete the picture, and sometimes also to give clues as to how unclear statements of the bible could be made sense of within the hebrew tradition as a whole. The Gospel of Thomas that I did read is according to some scholars likely to be the oldest account of the Jesus character.
In general I would discourage people from turning to books in hope of discovering the perfect spirituality or anything like that. Spirituality, in my opinion, can to a large extent only be hinted at. And I also do not think that The Gospel of Thomas or other apocrypha that I have looked into will solve much for those who are not happy with the bible. For me, they most certainly did not, and that is also why I did not bother to read all of the Nag Hammadi texts, for example. If one is into any kind of deep reality then I do think that there is better literature, but then again, texts are not a necessity for spirituality at all. My experience is that, yeah, reading a really good book can help you in some ways. But mostly, what I experienced from reading is that it helped me dispel false ideas that had been planted by various authorities and proselytizers, and not that it actually led me to depths of spirituality. On a few rare occasions, reading someone who attempted the impossible - to put in print something about deep reality - served to help me confirm that things I already experienced made a lot more sense than I had had the strength to assert on my own, but now I am not at all talking about the hebrew tradition. Other traditions were more useful. The most helpful were those extremely odd and truly rare modern commentators who obviously did not care much about pleasing anyone, but only about writing something that is worthwhile in and of itself. That could amount to pleasing the genuine seeker, but not academia, not church, not state, not party, not friends and relatives. I will not share what those were, however, for more than one reason. On the one hand, what was useful to me may not be useful to you. On the other hand, I am not in agreement even with those authors, and so, I think that it depends also on where the reader focuses if he will be edified or not.
A third reason not to share is of course that it is off topic. Sorry for going off on a tangent, but it began with the apocrypha that should not be ignored in the scientific effort to make sense of the new testament. They ought to be studied more than I did for the purpose of getting a more complete picture, scientifically.
In the sentences you quote at the top of this post, Nud is entirely wrong.
The Christian mystical and esoteric traditions do not rely on apocryphal writings. They use canonical texts, Greek philosophy, and the written descriptions of mystics. The tradition would be the same if the apocryphal texts had never existed.
I agree with you that we should analyze the New Testament and deal with it critically. To do this properly we should know how Christians have read and interpreted the text over many years. We can't do this if we just make up falsehoods.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_mysticism
Posts: 10525
Threads: 31
Joined: April 3, 2015
Reputation:
64
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
November 14, 2026 at 6:00 am
(November 14, 2026 at 12:12 am)Belacqua Wrote: [...]
The Christian mystical and esoteric traditions do not rely on apocryphal writings. They use canonical texts, Greek philosophy, and the written descriptions of mystics. The tradition would be the same if the apocryphal texts had never existed.
[...]
Sorry for the butt-in here, but just to say that after I kudosed and replied to that 'shitcanned' post by Nudger... which I had to look up the word 'apocrypha' to do... I did start to wonder if it was a misunderstanding on either of our parts, mine or his, in that in the 'New Man' book I'm talking about, it's not talking about anything that's not in the Bible... it's talking about the normal parables, and normal Gospels etc, not any hidden books that were not included in the normal, 'canonical' presumably, Bible... it's just a different interpretation of what already exists in the Bible, rather than a whole new interpretation in a whole new book that was omitted from the Bible and considered heretical or whatever... so it looks like either I've misunderstood what Nudger meant by that post, and/or he's misunderstood what that book is referring to and/or what I meant by 'writing intent'.
So it looks like a big misunderstanding all round to me, but I'll try and clear that up with a single, simple sentence: 'The New Man book is, or appears to me to be, a book where the author is claiming a non-literal interpretation of the existing books of the Bible, particularly the parables and Gospels, makes more logical sense, than a literal-only interpretation... sometimes, in addition to the literal meanings and sometimes instead of them'. As far as I'm concerned, the jury's still out for me on whether, or how, it's saying it can be both literal and non-literal at the same time... or to what extent it's saying that, if it is, but I haven't finished reading it yet, so hopefully I'll understand that more later. But so far, at least for some of it, it seems to be saying 'instead of' rather than 'in addition to'... for instance it explains the water into wine miracle as making little literal sense, but lots of non-literal sense (according to its own framework of 'esoteric'/psychological language meanings). Ie servants of the mother putting water ('higher truth') into stone ('literal truth') containers which then transforms into wine ('even higher understanding'), which the 'lower' servants/mother are aware of, because they put the water into the containers, but the receivers of the wine ('higher') are unaware of. Or something like that. It's pretty complicated yes, but nonetheless, I personally think this sort of psychological explanation makes far more logical sense than a literal-only one, so opens up a whole new approach to reading the Bible, but still remaining just as 'logical' if it is accepted that this was the sort of message that was actually intended by the writers, which personally I think it makes good arguments for that being the case.
Posts: 5022
Threads: 13
Joined: September 27, 2018
Reputation:
16
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
November 14, 2026 at 6:58 am
(This post was last modified: November 14, 2026 at 6:59 am by Belacqua.)
(November 14, 2026 at 6:00 am)emjay Wrote: Sorry for the butt-in here, but just to say that after I kudosed and replied to that 'shitcanned' post by Nudger... which I had to look up the word 'apocrypha' to do... I did start to wonder if it was a misunderstanding on either of our parts, mine or his, in that in the 'New Man' book I'm talking about, it's not talking about anything that's not in the Bible... it's talking about the normal parables, and normal Gospels etc, not any hidden books that were not included in the normal, 'canonical' presumably, Bible... it's just a different interpretation of what already exists in the Bible, rather than a whole new interpretation in a whole new book that was omitted from the Bible and considered heretical or whatever... so it looks like either I've misunderstood what Nudger meant by that post, and/or he's misunderstood what that book is referring to and/or what I meant by 'writing intent'.
So it looks like a big misunderstanding all round to me, but I'll try and clear that up with a single, simple sentence: 'The New Man book is, or appears to me to be, a book where the author is claiming a non-literal interpretation of the existing books of the Bible, particularly the parables and Gospels, makes more logical sense, than a literal-only interpretation... sometimes, in addition to the literal meanings and sometimes instead of them'. As far as I'm concerned, the jury's still out for me on whether, or how, it's saying it can be both literal and non-literal at the same time... or to what extent it's saying that, if it is, but I haven't finished reading it yet, so hopefully I'll understand that more later. But so far, at least for some of it, it seems to be saying 'instead of' rather than 'in addition to'... for instance it explains the water into wine miracle as making little literal sense, but lots of non-literal sense (according to its own framework of 'esoteric'/psychological language meanings). Ie servants of the mother putting water ('higher truth') into stone ('literal truth') containers which then transforms into wine ('even higher understanding'), which the 'lower' servants/mother are aware of, because they put the water into the containers, but the receivers of the wine ('higher') are unaware of. Or something like that. It's pretty complicated yes, but nonetheless, I personally think this sort of psychological explanation makes far more logical sense than a literal-only one, so opens up a whole new approach to reading the Bible, but still remaining just as 'logical' if it is accepted that this was the sort of message that was actually intended by the writers, which personally I think it makes good arguments for that being the case.
I'll take a wild guess about the claim that Christian mysticism came from apocrypha, and was condemned by the church. Probably the fantasy here is something about the so-called Gnostic Gospels, which were excluded from canon early on.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nag_Hammadi_library
Much of the writing in these is an overlap with canon, but some of what it says was rejected. But if the claim is that the "writing intent" of these is the only place where non-literal language is intended, that's ridiculous.
But I'll let the guy making the claim attempt to defend all that.
I think that even the strictest literalist agrees that some sentences in the Bible are metaphors. If the sentence "your eyes are doves" is literal, then we're reading about a grotesque monster.
There are also places where the authors themselves make it plain:
Quote:21 Tell me, you who want to be under the law, are you not aware of what the law says? 22 For it is written that Abraham had two sons, one by the slave woman and the other by the free woman. 23 His son by the slave woman was born according to the flesh, but his son by the free woman was born as the result of a divine promise.
24 These things are being taken figuratively: The women represent two covenants. One covenant is from Mount Sinai and bears children who are to be slaves: This is Hagar. 25 Now Hagar stands for Mount Sinai in Arabia and corresponds to the present city of Jerusalem, because she is in slavery with her children. 26 But the Jerusalem that is above is free, and she is our mother. 27
That's from Paul. He is usually taken to be a fairly influential guy in the history of Christianity.
In the 3rd century Origen argued that every verse in the Bible has three meanings: literal, moral, and spiritual. Later on Augustine increased this to 4: literal, allegorical, moral and anagogical. This was adapted from earlier Jewish methods. (And the names are a little misleading: "literal," here, means "the sense that the original author intended." So if the original author intended to write a metaphor, like the thing with the doves, then the literal meaning is metaphorical.) Of course these theologians believed the Bible was inspired by God, so they thought that the original author may not have known the full meaning of what he was writing.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_senses_of_Scripture
This doesn't depend entirely on divine instruction. Roland Barthes made a similar point about secular authors some years ago, in which he argued against limiting our study of a text to whatever the original intention was. The author is invariably a creature of his own time and place, and later people may see in his work messages which he didn't intend. This is especially true in texts which have been important for centuries, and have been interpreted by persuasive people. We can't read the Bible in the sense it had for its original readers, because in the intervening millennia other great thinkers have enriched our understanding of its themes.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Death_of_the_Author
As for the strange notion that Christian mysticism depends on the apocrypha, that's even less defensible. Similar mystical experiences were reported by non-Christian authors. Most notably Plotinus is said by his biographer to have achieved union with the One on several occasions. And again in Paul, he says "I knew a man in Christ more than fourteen years ago (whether in the body I cannot tell, or whether out of the body I cannot tell — God knoweth). Such a one was caught up to the third Heaven." Most people think Paul is speaking of himself here. This is in 2 Corinthians, not apocrypha.
Both Thomas Aquinas and Nicholas of Cusa reported strong mystical experiences, and they were not copying apocrypha, they were reporting what they felt. And Theresa of Avila and Catherine of Sienna and many others. Later mystics, like Boehme and Blake, are firmly in this tradition.
There's no question that ancient writers had a wide variety of methods at their disposal. And ancient readers were fully aware that non-literal expression was to be expected.
Posts: 10525
Threads: 31
Joined: April 3, 2015
Reputation:
64
RE: Is the general public educated enough on The New Testament?
November 14, 2026 at 7:32 am
(November 14, 2026 at 6:58 am)Belacqua Wrote: (November 14, 2026 at 6:00 am)emjay Wrote: Sorry for the butt-in here, but just to say that after I kudosed and replied to that 'shitcanned' post by Nudger... which I had to look up the word 'apocrypha' to do... I did start to wonder if it was a misunderstanding on either of our parts, mine or his, in that in the 'New Man' book I'm talking about, it's not talking about anything that's not in the Bible... it's talking about the normal parables, and normal Gospels etc, not any hidden books that were not included in the normal, 'canonical' presumably, Bible... it's just a different interpretation of what already exists in the Bible, rather than a whole new interpretation in a whole new book that was omitted from the Bible and considered heretical or whatever... so it looks like either I've misunderstood what Nudger meant by that post, and/or he's misunderstood what that book is referring to and/or what I meant by 'writing intent'.
So it looks like a big misunderstanding all round to me, but I'll try and clear that up with a single, simple sentence: 'The New Man book is, or appears to me to be, a book where the author is claiming a non-literal interpretation of the existing books of the Bible, particularly the parables and Gospels, makes more logical sense, than a literal-only interpretation... sometimes, in addition to the literal meanings and sometimes instead of them'. As far as I'm concerned, the jury's still out for me on whether, or how, it's saying it can be both literal and non-literal at the same time... or to what extent it's saying that, if it is, but I haven't finished reading it yet, so hopefully I'll understand that more later. But so far, at least for some of it, it seems to be saying 'instead of' rather than 'in addition to'... for instance it explains the water into wine miracle as making little literal sense, but lots of non-literal sense (according to its own framework of 'esoteric'/psychological language meanings). Ie servants of the mother putting water ('higher truth') into stone ('literal truth') containers which then transforms into wine ('even higher understanding'), which the 'lower' servants/mother are aware of, because they put the water into the containers, but the receivers of the wine ('higher') are unaware of. Or something like that. It's pretty complicated yes, but nonetheless, I personally think this sort of psychological explanation makes far more logical sense than a literal-only one, so opens up a whole new approach to reading the Bible, but still remaining just as 'logical' if it is accepted that this was the sort of message that was actually intended by the writers, which personally I think it makes good arguments for that being the case.
I'll take a wild guess about the claim that Christian mysticism came from apocrypha, and was condemned by the church. Probably the fantasy here is something about the so-called Gnostic Gospels, which were excluded from canon early on.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nag_Hammadi_library
Much of the writing in these is an overlap with canon, but some of what it says was rejected. But if the claim is that the "writing intent" of these is the only place where non-literal language is intended, that's ridiculous.
But I'll let the guy making the claim attempt to defend all that.
I think that even the strictest literalist agrees that some sentences in the Bible are metaphors. If the sentence "your eyes are doves" is literal, then we're reading about a grotesque monster.
There are also places where the authors themselves make it plain:
Quote:21 Tell me, you who want to be under the law, are you not aware of what the law says? 22 For it is written that Abraham had two sons, one by the slave woman and the other by the free woman. 23 His son by the slave woman was born according to the flesh, but his son by the free woman was born as the result of a divine promise.
24 These things are being taken figuratively: The women represent two covenants. One covenant is from Mount Sinai and bears children who are to be slaves: This is Hagar. 25 Now Hagar stands for Mount Sinai in Arabia and corresponds to the present city of Jerusalem, because she is in slavery with her children. 26 But the Jerusalem that is above is free, and she is our mother. 27
That's from Paul. He is usually taken to be a fairly influential guy in the history of Christianity.
In the 3rd century Origen argued that every verse in the Bible has three meanings: literal, moral, and spiritual. Later on Augustine increased this to 4: literal, allegorical, moral and anagogical. This was adapted from earlier Jewish methods. (And the names are a little misleading: "literal," here, means "the sense that the original author intended." So if the original author intended to write a metaphor, like the thing with the doves, then the literal meaning is metaphorical.) Of course these theologians believed the Bible was inspired by God, so they thought that the original author may not have known the full meaning of what he was writing.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_senses_of_Scripture
This doesn't depend entirely on divine instruction. Roland Barthes made a similar point about secular authors some years ago, in which he argued against limiting our study of a text to whatever the original intention was. The author is invariably a creature of his own time and place, and later people may see in his work messages which he didn't intend. This is especially true in texts which have been important for centuries, and have been interpreted by persuasive people. We can't read the Bible in the sense it had for its original readers, because in the intervening millennia other great thinkers have enriched our understanding of its themes.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Death_of_the_Author
As for the strange notion that Christian mysticism depends on the apocrypha, that's even less defensible. Similar mystical experiences were reported by non-Christian authors. Most notably Plotinus is said by his biographer to have achieved union with the One on several occasions. And again in Paul, he says "I knew a man in Christ more than fourteen years ago (whether in the body I cannot tell, or whether out of the body I cannot tell — God knoweth). Such a one was caught up to the third Heaven." Most people think Paul is speaking of himself here. This is in 2 Corinthians, not apocrypha.
Both Thomas Aquinas and Nicholas of Cusa reported strong mystical experiences, and they were not copying apocrypha, they were reporting what they felt. And Theresa of Avila and Catherine of Sienna and many others. Later mystics, like Boehme and Blake, are firmly in this tradition.
There's no question that ancient writers had a wide variety of methods at their disposal. And ancient readers were fully aware that non-literal expression was to be expected.
I'll just say a few things for the record. 1) I'm not so much a literalist that I don't know what a metaphor is or see and accept its obvious usage in the Bible, sometimes, 2) My replies in this thread have been specifically about the book 'the New Man' and only about that... if I have inadvertently stood on other people's toes in this discussion, then I'm sorry about that, that was not the intent... so whatever the bigger theme in this thread is I don't really understand it too much, and only really addressing this (perhaps too?) tangential subject... sorry again for that, but sadly that's just my nature to easily go off on tangents, and 3) one of the main things of interest to me in this book, in simple terms... in 'switch flipping' terms, as I've described... is seeing the claimed miracles themselves as non-literal instead of literal... that's what's particularly new to me in this book, and what is 'flipping switches' for me. I.e. it essentially raising the question for me 'what if miracle x was never claimed as a literal miracle in the first place'. That's what I'm personally finding so thought provoking about this book.
|