Convert me if you can

[Regens Küchl]

@ Deist Paladin, my dear soon to be converted muslim

Something happened to mine and your post at page 5. After reading your post 44 I countered every argument therein in my post 45.

But yesterday I had to see that in post 45 not only most of my arguments had vanished but my single remaining argument had your answer already attached to it, making it look like it come from me. But in the post under my name the sentence :
"Makes me think they preserved it for illogical reasons. So what?" must have come from you for I did not write it !

Not only did most of my post vanish but it also must have merged with your answer. Very odd.
Perhaps a new wonder of Islam, wouldnt you say so too ? Allah plays with thi thread as a sign that you should join Islam.

Anyway, I learned that you have cultivated three ground-reasons for your distrusting Islam more than christianity. We will work on your belief from hereon. Your three reasons (which I will successfully counter in time) are :

1) Why should Mohammed (blessed be his name) have known more about Jesus than the christians of his time ?

2) If Mohammed (blessed be his name) were right, that would make Jesus in your eyes a "Failed Prophet" and in your eyes that would be some paradox that discredits Islam even if Islam is right.

3) You say that the claim for christianity has more evidence (lets at this point not yet talk about the substance and scrutinizing of both evidences) You made the following list for Islam :

Islam's Claim: God spoke to Muhammad

Evidence Offered:
1. "Look how beautiful the poetry of the Koran is." (appeal to art)
2. "Islam has grown and so it must be true." (appeal to popularity)
3. "There's scientific knowledge in the Koran that Muhammad couldn't have known."

OK, so far your critic on Islam. Now we will scrutinitize it systhemathically.

At first I have to beg you humbly for something; make that list under point 3 of your ground reasons in the same way for christianity.

Write down christianitys claim(s) and than number the evidences 1, 2 , 3, and on.

But please do not forget to add as evidence 3 the alleged fullfillments of soandsomany biblical prophecies, for them are the analogy for Islams scientific knowledge of the Koran.

OK, awaiting your list, please.