Refuting typical arguments

[robvalue]

Yup, I can cut like five arms off from the same person, but they've still got two arms. So they can't have been real arms. They were extra ones stuffed with straw.

I cut off the real ones too, and find out they weren't real either. More straw. The actual real arms are being hidden under a jumper.

I can understand theists being reluctant to say the real reason, and that's assuming they actually know themselves. I think they assume an atheist will think the reason is stupid. I wonder why they would come to that conclusion on our behalf, without us even having to hear it? That should tell them something, really.

But I'm probably over-reaching here