(March 31, 2016 at 7:35 pm)Jehanne Wrote:(March 31, 2016 at 7:32 pm)athrock Wrote: The problem of evil was one attempt at this, but it has been refuted by Plantinga, and no one considers the intellectual problem of evil to be the knock-down argument that it was previously. The emotional problem of evil still seems to have some punch simply because hearts ARE obviously moved by the pain they experience and observe.
Maybe Plantinga considers it to be "refuted", but I certainly do not, and there are atheistic philosophers who do not agree with Plantinga on this. It's a sidebar, yes, but I have listened to Plantinga (on the Closer to Truth series), and I find his arguments wanting, if not somewhat pathetic.
Pathetic?
That doesn't seem to be the consensus among professional philosophers.However, to be fair, what can you tell me about the position of ATHEIST philosophers who have interacted with Plantiga's work on the Problem of Evil?
Are there any websites, blogs or online articles that you recommend from one or more of the "big boys"?
