On Logic and Alternate Universes

[Edwardo Piet]

No one's discussing whether or not the law of identity is false.  The law of identity is true, here, in th OP's hypothetical...it simply doesn't exist in that other place.

Not possible. The non-existence of the Law of Identity implies the law of identity itself. By virtue of not being true it has the identity of not being true and not the identity of not not being true which means the law of identity is still there. You can never escape the law of non-contradiction or the law of identity. It's logically impossible. "Oh in this universe the law of identity doesn't apply" does no good because that itself is still an expression of TLOI