What is wrong with FW?

[Little Rik]

Why atheists hate to hear that?

God or not God FREE WILL still affect our lives in the good or the bad so why atheists dislike to hear about it so much?  

So....is the assailant raping the girl of his own free will even as karma is using said assailant to punish said girl for kicking three dogs in a previous life...?

Could the assailant refuse to be the vehicle of karma..would karma then have to pick someone else?  What if the second person in the resignation-chain just isn;t a rapist, does he karmicly become one so that justice can be fulfilled?  Is he, then, karmicly accountable for his actions?  I ask, because it sounds like we might be dealing with a firefighter who moonlights as an arsonist.

Or is it, ultimately, that the efficacy of the karmic vehicle is under our own control, such that..were enough people to refuse to conform to the karmic scheme...karmic satisfaction could be a non-event?

1) The problem with making so many suppositions and speculations like you do is that is very easy to get lost in a labyrinth especially if you never practice the art of intuition, beside what difference would make whether someone would have to experience his-her bad karma by a tile falling from the roof in your head, by being raped or by any other mishap?  

2) Whether you believe in karma or not it wouldn't make any difference as far as the punishment is concerned but it would make a lot of difference if you understand that a debt must be repaid because in this case you do not build up that anger and rage that would only make the thing worse.  

---

Well, well yog.

I have to admire your resolution in trying to get up after your continuous K.O. and try to resume the fightings.

When you live in the fairyland everything make sense even the non sense.

I don't think I've ever encountered such breathtaking stupidity before.

Smile yog even if now you end up in a mental dead lane.  

Sooner or later you will wake up and grow up so you will understand that plants turn into animals, animals into humans and humans into God and all your dogmas will end down in the rubbish bin of the past.

Good luck.