God can make infinitely more special/valuable things than this universe

[Belacqua]

Of course I wouldn't do it like that under the claim of "all powerful" and especially with "all loving".

OK, so we're back to the idea that you know what an all powerful and all loving God would do, and you judge that those things aren't happening. 

Sorry, the logic isn't there.

You have a very clear image of what God would be doing if he were real. Anyone who accepts your premises -- that a God would have used time more efficiently to invent people sooner, and that he would allow less human suffering -- would no doubt agree with you.