God can make infinitely more special/valuable things than this universe

[Belacqua]

Nope sorry, you do not get to blame me for reacting to the parameters I am not claiming merely for responding to crappy logic.

You might as well be arguing, " How do you know why Santa gives you presents or puts coal in your stocking since you are not Santa."

Maybe I'm not understanding you. Let me put it another way. 

Do you find this syllogism sound?

~ If there were a good God, X, Y, and Z would happen.
~ X, Y, and Z don't happen.
~ Therefore, there isn't a good God. 

The trouble I see with this is that we have no way of knowing if the initial premise is true. We can say what we prefer, or we can say what we think we would do in his shoes, but there is no way for us to know, really. 

But if my logic is bad here please let me know. I may be mischaracterizing your argument.