How to select which supernatural to believe?

[Jehanne]

There can never be natural evidence for the supernatural.

If something is a cause of natural events, it becomes part of the natural world, and can be studied.  A God that interacts with the natural world must have a natural aspect.  Only that natural aspect can be investigated.

Nope, that is not true.
In this case, there are actually only two important words. Love and mercy.
Because of these two, God, that colossal power beyond the grasp of man, speaks to man in his own language and in a way that he can understand.
He comes down to our level because of his mercy.

Let me guess, you watch The Hallmark Channel?