(May 31, 2012 at 6:38 am)NoMoreFaith Wrote:(May 31, 2012 at 6:24 am)StatCrux Wrote: That would be a "no" then...
Nobody said that. We said it was an irrelevant question.
Reverse the question.
Would great art exist without religion?
1. Great art exists that is not inspired by religion
2. Religion inspires great pieces of art
3. If there were no religion, great art would still exist.
4. Therefore religion is non-essential to great art.
/end.
I didn't use the word "essential" I said religion inspires people to create great works of art. Its the visible expression of connecting with the transcendent and luminous. Atheism creates a mindset that closes peoples minds to that aspect of existence and stifles creativity. Is it merely coincidence that the majority of great works of art, poetry, music etc are created from a mind that believes in some from of transcendent reality? While not "essential" it definitely is conducive to great works of art.