(October 26, 2012 at 1:12 pm)Darkstar Wrote: Not in its entirety...It has multiple references to miracles performed by NT authors.
Quote:Which prompted me to find this:http://www.answering-christianity.com/je...racles.htm. What makes Jesus so special, then?First, my malware software said this site was unsafe, so I didn't see it.
Second, I generally don't respond to "arguments" which are just a link. I expect you to quote or summarize the relevant material. (Youtubes are straight ouot of the question!)
Quote:I'm just going by their reasoning...I don't agree that it is evidence either.OK.
Quote:Oh wait, isn't that an argument from silence to say that because we haven't found that text, it probably doesn't exist?It would be if I made that argument. I made the positive argument that the earliest Christian documents contain the miraculous. Critics can and do speculate that such texts existed, but the burden of proof is on them.
Quote:Does that mean I can say that the Romans never wrote about Jesus performing any miracles, and because miracle claims of the time were common, that means he probably didn't perform any?Sure - all you need to do is show a whole bunch of Roman contemporaneous documentations of foreign religions' miracle claims in the first century, and you'll have a valid argument from silence. We've been over this already.