Jesus, Least Fit Moral Judge

[Drich]

Before I reply to you, you have misunderstood my entire post and therefore replied with such misunderstanding, making it pointless to reply to half of it.

Missluckie26 said:
Before you go spouting off that I indeed dictate what others do myself in terms of not wanting others to murder or rape--consider this. You were put on this earth, so was I. We are equals. If you kill me or rape me, then you are treading upon my rights as a human being and I must dictate that you can't do that, in order to protect my own existence.

Drich said:
WOW, so before you go any further let me get this straight. It is ok to murder if you deem it ok?


I did not in any of my posts, say it was all right to murder. Factually the opposite, actually. I may dictate through a law that you can't murder me, and thus have there be a punishment for it but that punishment would definitely not be death, or I'd be as bad as the murderer. Punishment meaning, rendering you incapable of hurting. Even hitler, I wouldn't have murdered I just woulda locked his crazy ass up. I can't see how you interpreted any of my anti-murder quotes, as that I would murder to keep a murderer from murdering. Nope, not real. Not happening. Please re-read my posts and reply accordingly to what I was saying, thanks.
[/quote]

I left you an out. In that I summed the following statement up as 'murder':

You'd tell him to F off wouldn't you? That's you, to me. It's actually more logical to believe that there isn't anywhere after death, for the mere fact that religion uses it to get what it wants from people, in life. Charlatan comes to mind, when I think about any person on earth who tells me that if I don't do what they want or live like they want me to, then I will be thrown into an alleged sadistic eternal lake of fire. Before you go spouting off that I indeed dictate what others do myself in terms of not wanting others to murder or rape--consider this. You were put on this earth, so was I. We are equals. If you kill me or rape me, then you are treading upon my rights as a human being and I must dictate that you can't do that, in order to protect my own existence.

I simply took your statement to it's logical conclusion. In that the only way to stop someone bent on raping or murdering another person is to kill them.

At this point you had two options. Restate and clarify your intertionaly ellusive wording, or set up a default situation where my understanding of your statement effectivly ends the conversation.
It seems as if you've decided to end the conversation. I say that because less than 1/3 of the total conversation speaks to your position on murder, the conversation could easily continue on all other fronts.

However, If you wish to continue this conversation then answer the following with an yes or no:
If I and/or someone else in whom you hate set a weekly appointment to Rape you, and NOTHING else could be done to stop us, beside you killing your attackers. Would you Murder them?

Again only answer if your interesting in continuing this conversation. If however you did set this conversation up to default on my failure to comply to your request. Then I'll allow you to make a snarky comment without producing a follow up. (in essence giving you the last word) Just don't ask any questions, that I may be compelled to answer.


If this is it I look forward to our next discussion.