Would you rather live under an oppressive religious or securlar government?

[FallentoReason]

I have two different answers depending on if I were Christian or not.

Ok, I can somewhat predict what way you would sway...

As a Christian, I would go with the secular government because I would not want to be forced to follow any belief patterns that would be in conflict with my own.

Are you serious?! What if the belief just happened to be... oh, I dunno... Christianity?

Now if I were atheist, I would probably go with the religious government on the basis I would probably live much longer under such a system. Religion has always been a great tool to create stability with less bloodshed than under similarly oppressive secular governments.

WHAT. Hellooo... crusades? Inquisition?

Sure, I probably had to follow their rules and worship, but what meaning would worshiping really have?

It gets worse; how could it ever be a good idea to allow an ancient book access to government so that it could apply its superstition as law?

Only 16 or so people were killed in the Salem Witch Trials, but the fear created by it made it seem so much worse...religion can kill a few dozen and their deaths become great motivators for the people to get back in line. Kill one person, scare a thousand into submission...probably because the fear it also meant damnation as well.

With secular governments, they have resorted to wiping out whole villages in their nations to achieve the same level of fear and control...this is probably because those who rule with religion already have a sense of legitimacy that others must prove through force to similarly maintain.

*facepalm*

I give you 2/10 for this apologetic tactic to shoehorn your belief into us. From the first paragraph I could tell you weren't answering your own question sincerely. Of course you would like to live under a religious government as a Christian. Naturally, you want entire countries to convert to Christianity in the ideal world.